Books Stephen King Recommends discussion
June-July 2012 Group Read
>
Overal Impressions (SPOILER ALERT)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Debra
(new)
Jun 03, 2012 12:28AM

reply
|
flag

*Love lingers*; and *that the dead can't save themselves, someone else must do it*.
I am eager to discuss as best I can along the way; as I was listening to the audio I didn't take notes at the end of each part, so will depend on others comments to tip-toe around revealing too much, too soon. I may look for a print copy at the library to guide my comments.
Koryta is such a great writer; I will definitely continue to read his stuff! This book was relentless, and I was on the edge of my seat all the way through; so anxious about Arlen and Paul and Rebecca. I wanted them to just get out of Corridor County and make tracks! I like the supernatural twist, too. It didn't overwhelm the story; just added a bit of spice and intrigue.
I'm going to pace myself on adding my comments to each section, so others can catch up.
I'm going to pace myself on adding my comments to each section, so others can catch up.

Debra wrote: "Koryta is such a great writer; I will definitely continue to read his stuff! This book was relentless, and I was on the edge of my seat all the way through; so anxious about Arlen and Paul and Rebecca.......! I like the supernatural twist, too. It didn't overwhelm the story; just added a bit of spice and intrigue"
.

Maybe I need to talk it out. I'm ready anytime you are Debra and Ann..... help me - what am I missing???

It's hard to like a book with characters you can't like much.
So then at the end I was intrigued with the twists on the storyline, the backstory on Arlen grabbed me in, then the supernatural aspect of Arlen's gift was compelling as he went on his search for Paul. That plus the contemplation of the type of psychic knowledge Arlen lived with redeemed the book for me.

But now there is another question that is left unanswered, Arlen saw the smoke in his eyes, and his skeleton body, but he didn't die, Paul was able to get him to the hospital and they saved his life, now, why would the author have that happen if he was going to allow Arlen to live in the end... that was odd to me..

I was intrigued by his assertion of what he'd learned in the Belleau Wood, that the dead couldn't save themselves- he could help the men with smoke in their eyes, but they couldn't ever help themselves.
Evidentially Paul could help Arlen ( and to great effect!!)
Linda wrote: "But now there is another question that is left unanswered, Arlen saw the smoke in his eyes, and his skeleton body, but he didn't die, Paul was able to get him to the hospital and they saved his life, now, why would the author have that happen if he was going to allow Arlen to live in the end... that was odd to me.. h..."
Although I expected Arlen to die, I wasn't too surprised when he didn't. After all, he was able to save people when he saw death in their eyes, if he was able to lead them on a different path. He saved some men when he was at Belleau Woods in the war, and it is implied he could have saved the men on the train if they'd just listen to him. So... why couldn't he be saved too, if someone or something intervened on his behalf like Paul did?
I gave this book a 4. It was a hard book to read in some ways because of the unlikeable characters, but the story was so good, well-written, and atmospheric, I couldn't help ending up liking it a lot. And it still haunts me, so that says something about it.
I gave this book a 4. It was a hard book to read in some ways because of the unlikeable characters, but the story was so good, well-written, and atmospheric, I couldn't help ending up liking it a lot. And it still haunts me, so that says something about it.

Debra wrote: " And it still haunts me, so that says something about it. "



For those of you without the experience of the audio book, when Arlen started to have one of his psychic moments seeing the dead, there was a musical overlay. The music was ethereal and a bit creepy.
Hmmm... sounds like I might not have enjoyed listening to this one, but ya never know. Sorry the background noises and voices pulled you out of the story, Amber!