Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!)
>
Books:
graphic-novel
(282)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
|
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0593532805
| 9780593532805
| 0593532805
| 4.21
| 3,805
| Oct 10, 2023
| Oct 10, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
In a Nutshell: An excellent standalone graphic novel about sibling bonds/breaks on a road trip. The OwnVoices Muslim-American perspective adds a lot o
In a Nutshell: An excellent standalone graphic novel about sibling bonds/breaks on a road trip. The OwnVoices Muslim-American perspective adds a lot of personal depth. Absolutely recommended! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This is the second book of the Huda graphic novel series, and though this continues into the next stage of Huda’s life, the book works perfectly as a standalone. Huda, who has just completed her freshman year, is taken aback when her parents announce a road trip to Florida. Travelling with three of her four sisters isn’t going to be easy on a 24-hour long journey, but it is a worthwhile sacrifice in order to see Disneyworld. The journey and vacation cover Huda’s relationship with each of her sisters and her parents, her continued struggles over her Muslim identity, and the difficulty of fitting in as a visible Muslim in a non-Muslim society. Everything about this graphic novel, right from the dedication to the acknowledgements is written straight from the heart. The background to the key characters is provided in Book One: ‘Huda F Are You?’, but we get to know the individual personalities of the Fahmy sisters in this second book. The difficulties of a road trip, sibling conflicts and connections, parental partiality, religious identity, and social struggles are just some of the themes this book handles. I love how all the topics come out naturally through the plot and don’t feel forced in. While the themes are intense, Huda balances it with plenty of light moments. Her shoulder angel and devil also offer great comic relief. This book continues the trend from Book One, depicting Huda’s self-identity issues through captions at the base of a statue pedestal. Again, it works perfectly to indicate Huda’s thoughts about herself after that particular event. As one of the few (only?) contemporary OwnVoices Muslim graphic novels, this series offers a lot of insight into a practising Muslim’s life without going into information overload. Though the author makes it clear that the events are semi-fictionalised, there is a strong undertone of realism to the narrative. The racism, the culturally-offensive remarks, the offhand comments about the hijab and abaya – all seem to spring from real-life occurrences. The illustrations are in the same style as always. Simple linework, cartoonish expressions, exaggerated reactions – excellent for the story. All in all, a great continuation to the series. With a balance between light-heartedness and seriousness, this graphic novel highlights several practical conundrums at the personal, familial, religious, and societal level. Much recommended to lovers of OwnVoices graphic novels. While the book can be read as a standalone, I’d strongly suggest reading the books in the right order as we get to know the family’s background only in Book One. 4.5 stars. *Huda F* thinks this high rating is an April Fool’s prank? This was a library read. Moving on to Book Three: ‘Huda F Wants to Know?’ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Mar 28, 2025
|
Apr 2025
|
Mar 28, 2025
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
0593324331
| 9780593324332
| B08VRRLXQR
| 4.16
| 9,759
| Nov 23, 2021
| Nov 23, 2021
|
it was amazing
|
In a Nutshell: A OwnVoices graphic novel about the experiences of a hijabi American (of Arab-Muslim background) as a high-schooler in America. Excelle
In a Nutshell: A OwnVoices graphic novel about the experiences of a hijabi American (of Arab-Muslim background) as a high-schooler in America. Excellent combination of humour and meaningful themes and social discrimination. Much recommended! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I first discovered Huda Fahmy’s work when I stumbled upon the delightful “That Can Be Arranged: A Muslim Love Story”, a graphic novel about how she met her husband. Her wit and her intelligence both are on ample display in her books and her Instagram page. So when I got the ARC of her upcoming work – the third book of the Huda series, I finally decided to catch up on the first two. I adore the name of this series! Using her own name in this twisty pun is such a creative idea, especially when it represents the way her name is mangled by many USians. This first book of the Huda series deals with Huda’s experiences as a Hijabi student in Dearborn, Michigan. Huda’s dad had immigrated to the USA from Egypt when he was a teen and after marriage, brought his wife to the country, intending for a short-term stay until he completed his education. However, the family ended up staying in the USA with their five daughters. Despite being a Born-American, Huda was still looked upon as an outsider, mainly due to her hijab. This graphic novel details some semi-fictionalised experiences of her high-school years, when she was trying to understand her true identity, not just as a Muslim girl but also as a teenager. The story ends each stage of Huda’s identity crisis with a full-page graphic of her as a sort of statuette on a pedestal, with a caption indicating her latest self-loathing label such as “Huda F is a Coward” or “Huda F is a Fake”. I loved how well this idea worked not just to incorporate the titular pun into the plot but also to show us where Huda stood with respect to herself at that stage of the narrative. The book depicts the genuine confusion of the troublesome teen years, when one is torn between staying true to oneself and accepting whatever others say just to fit in. The tremendous racism faced by Muslims in America even at the school level also comes out clearly through the narrative. (I can't begin to imagine how much worse it might be now under the present administration’s anti-DEI policy.) I loved seeing Huda’s mom again, just as spunky as she was in “That Can Be Arranged”. Huda’s other family members also get a little page space. I’d love to know them better in subsequent books. The story ends at a good point, so this book can be considered a standalone read with no cliffhanger ending. The illustrations are in standard Huda Fahmy style. If you follow her page on Instagram, you will know the kind of graphics you can expect. Though simplistic in colouring and character expressions, the art style really works for the story. It’s always an advantage when the author is also the illustrator. All in all, I absolutely loved this novel with its amalgamation of fun + serious. Though it has a lighthearted approach on the whole, it details several important themes and topics affecting minority Muslim teens in the USA. Much recommended to all graphic novels readers looking for a meaningful semi-fictional OwnVoices work that’s rooted in reality. 4.5 stars. *Huda F* can stop me from rounding this up? This was a library read. Looking forward to Book Two: ‘Huda F Cares?’ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Mar 23, 2025
|
Mar 28, 2025
|
Mar 23, 2025
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
0063075970
| 9780063075979
| B0DCZMR3VR
| unknown
| 4.47
| 19
| unknown
| May 13, 2025
|
it was amazing
|
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade/teen graphic novel about a mermaid and a firebird trying to fix a magical problem from the past. Excellent plot, magic,
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade/teen graphic novel about a mermaid and a firebird trying to fix a magical problem from the past. Excellent plot, magic, worldbuilding, and characters. A wonderful conclusion to the Atana duology. Not to be read as a standalone. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: I won't give any plot details as this is a direct sequel to the first book and I don’t want to go into spoilers. So all you can know for now is that Atana and Ren, along with their companions, try to sort out all issues raised in the first book. Their journey isn't easy, but their friendship and their determination are as strong as ever. This second book of the Atana duology continues immediately from the ending of the first Atana book: “Atana and the Firebird”. As such, it is not to be read as a standalone. Book One had impressed me with its magical beings and the plot, but the number of dangling threads and the intricacy of the multiple backstories had left me reluctant to hit the 5-star mark. It was clear that the sequel would need to fill in all the gaps in the plot without making it seem cluttered or convenient. Thankfully, this book does a great job of bringing all the subplots to a neat finish. Though we know the end goal of this story – to sort out all the unresolved arcs from Book One, especially the part connected to Atana’s backstory – there are still a few surprises awaiting us herein, along with many humorous moments. There are also quite a few memorable quotes connected to self-acceptance and self-confidence. On the whole, this book doesn’t feel as complicated as Book One because it doesn’t introduce many new tangles; it mainly attempts to sort out the knots from the earlier muddle. Atana, Ren, Cosmos, Celosia, and Suah all return in this story in key roles. There are some new characters as well, connected to Atana and Ren. We don’t get to know these new entrants intimately as the primary focus of the story is on the pending arcs of Book One. However, we learn just enough about them to get a hang of their behaviour. Kudos to the author for providing depth to a character even within a limited page space. The cast is quite female-dominant, with every single on-page character being female. One of the characters uses the they/them pronouns, and there are a couple of Sapphic relationships hinted at. However, just as in the first book, these are barely elaborated upon. I wish the title hadn’t mentioned “Jade Mermaid.” In the first book, Atana meets the firebird in the first chapter itself, so there’s no spoiler. However, we don’t get to know even about the existence of the jade mermaid until much, much later in the story, so the surprise is kinda spoilt by the title. The worldbuilding is much clearer this time as we get to see the entire magic system instead of just bits and pieces of it in passing. Each of the three worlds has a distinct look in terms of both features and characters. The illustrations are just as beautiful as in the first book. They feel like an ode to Studio Ghibli (without any stupid AI intervention, of course.) I just wish I could figure out why the Witch Queen’s eyes are always hidden. All in all, this is a worthy conclusion to the duology, and as it satisfied all the doubts and questions I had after reading the first book, I enjoyed it even better. Definitely recommended, but only to those who have read the first book. Both the stories are lovely, so this set will be a nice addition to your graphic-novel/fantasy-loving teen’s TBR. 4.5 stars. My thanks to HarperCollins Children's Books and HarperAlley for providing the DRC of “Atana and the Jade Mermaid” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Apr 09, 2025
|
Apr 09, 2025
|
Mar 21, 2025
|
Kindle Edition
| ||||||||||||||
0593855655
| 9780593855652
| B0D8KB157D
| unknown
| 4.45
| 285
| Apr 01, 2025
| Apr 01, 2025
|
it was amazing
|
In a Nutshell: Wow! The third graphic novel in the Huda series and the best one so far, which is saying a lot in such a high-performing series. Tackli
In a Nutshell: Wow! The third graphic novel in the Huda series and the best one so far, which is saying a lot in such a high-performing series. Tackling two serious topics but handled with a balanced amount of lightheartedness. Absolutely loved this OwnVoices work for its sensitive portrayal of such a tricky personal issue. Much, much recommended! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This is the third graphic novel of the Huda series, or as I like to call it, the Huda F series. While each book works perfectly as a standalone, it helps to go through the series in the right order. Considering the high quality of the storytelling (I’ve rated all three books 4.5+ stars), you are in for a sensory delight. The book begins with Huda being in her junior year and now prepping for college. She has a detailed plan charted out for the next two years: do everything possible to get into her dream college with a full scholarship. Easy-peasy for such an achiever, right? Right! Until Mama and Baba throw a spanner in the works: they announce that they are getting a divorce. After this announcement that comes out of nowhere, Huda and her sisters are devastated. Huda in particular is worried about what this means for her future. Will her carefully planned year be thrown awry after her grades and her relationships with her family and friends start tanking? I must admit that I was a bit sad when I read the GR blurb of this book. To learn that this book was about Fahmy’s parents’ divorce was shocking. I have read four of her graphic novels so far, and though her father doesn’t make as much of an appearance in her books as her mother does, I have come to love both of their characters, even with their shortcomings. As the book series is semi-autobiographical, I can only hope that the author has made her peace with this heartbreaking event after all these years, and that writing this book has been a cathartic experience. Sending her loads of hugs! Divorce is fairly common in many countries these days, but this doesn’t make it less painful for the family, especially the kids. However, in conservative cultures and religions, divorce is still frowned upon and many elders still look at divorced couples (particularly at wives) with disdain. This orthodox outlook towards separations is present in India as well. (Which is probably why only 1% of marriages in India end in divorce as against 43% in the USA. Couples here either don’t have the choice of separating due to family pressure or they are afraid of the “scandal”.) Some scenes in this book that might appear exaggerated to Western eyes are conversations I have actually heard in real life. (Older Indian women are notorious for their bitchy gossip. Fingers crossed I don’t turn into one in my senior years!) So to truly understand why this Arab Muslim family struggles so hard to get through this change, you must keep their cultural background in mind and know that it is much, much tougher to deal with something as personal as a divorce in the face of such intense and judgemental public scrutiny. A story of divorce is guaranteed to be an emotional read. Divorce plots are never just about a couple deciding to split. Every decision comes with repercussions. In this case, we get to see the impact of this momentous announcement on the five Fahmy sisters, each of whom seems to tackle the uncertainty in their own way. As such, a great chunk of the story also tackles the important topic of mental health. It doesn’t show a standardised narrative but highlights various ways by which such issues manifest, whether through coping strategies or escape mechanisms, and how this can be tackled realistically. I appreciate the author’s sticking to realism and not showing a magic-wand solution by which all problems disappear after one therapeutic session. As you might have guessed, this is the most serious and the most emotional of the three Huda books so far. Yet, somehow, the author also manages to make it the most uplifting. I love how she ends the story on a ray of hope instead of trying to portray an overly shiny rainbow of happiness. Divorce is always messy, and this sanguine ending works so much better for the story. Does all this mean that the book doesn’t contain any humour? Au contraire! I am SO impressed at how the author managed to insert comical scenes even through what might be tough emotional moments to go through in reality. The funny scenes never jar, nor do they take away from the intensity of the situation. As these books are aimed at readers teen and above, such lighter moments help keep the book from getting too depressing. All of the above is handled from the OwnVoices Muslim viewpoint. The author always begins with a disclaimer that her story doesn't represent all Muslims or Muslim experiences. But her grasp of her faith and the way her family follows religious requirements help add a genuineness to her storytelling. The writing clearly depicts the role that religion and religious beliefs play in tackling major life changes. I love that their approach is balanced between using religion for emotional support and using external practical assistance such as speaking to a therapist. I respect the author for never ever dissing her faith but always showing it in a positive light and correcting public misconceptions about Islamic beliefs. Two wonderful stylistic choices that continue from the earlier two books are the “Huda F” pedestal declarations about who “Huda F is”, and Huda’s constant companions: her shoulder angel and devil. Don’t miss out the epilogue about mental health, which comes after the Acknowledgements section. The book even ends with a list of helpful free resources for mental health support, including a special helpline for young Muslims – a considerate and praiseworthy gesture. All in all, this is one heck of an OwnVoices book, tackling a serious topic in just the right manner. By highlighting so many practical topics that many teens deal with, the book is easily a must-read, and the best of the series so far. I had rated the first two Huda books 4.5 stars, which itself is not a rating I give freely. To surpass even that high level is just an indication of how much this book touched me. I am not sure if there will be more books in this series, but if there are, *Huda F* is gonna stop me from reading them? No one! Recommended with all my heart to every reader aged teen and above who enjoys OwnVoices graphic novels offering a relatable and genuine story. 4.75 stars. My thanks to Colored Pages Book Tours, Penguin Young Readers Group, Dial Books, and author Huda Fahmy for a complimentary digital ARC of 'Huda F Wants to Know?' via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. Also check out the first two books of this outstanding series: Book One: Huda F Are You? Book Two: Huda F Cares? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Apr 2025
|
Apr 07, 2025
|
Mar 18, 2025
|
Kindle Edition
| ||||||||||||||
0593578104
| 9780593578100
| 0593578104
| 4.47
| 15
| Apr 2025
| Apr 01, 2025
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A graphic novel that narrates stories from the Bible, using Cleopas’s encounter with Jesus on the way to Emmaus as the foundation. Inno
In a Nutshell: A graphic novel that narrates stories from the Bible, using Cleopas’s encounter with Jesus on the way to Emmaus as the foundation. Innovative in concept and execution. Excellent (and racially-authentic) illustrations. Might be a bit tricky for the target audience of middle-graders as the narrative isn't linear. But adult supervision will help. Recommended. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Children are always attracted to books with illustrations. So using a graphic novel to teach them stories from the Bible is a wonderful idea. But this book doesn’t just stop at this basic intent. Rather, its presentation sets it apart from other similar works. The story uses Cleopas’s trip from Jerusalem to Emmaus as the setting. As the Gospel of Luke mentions only Cleopas by name in its references to this journey that takes place on the day of Jesus’s resurrection, this book adds some fictional characters – Miriam (Cleopas’s wife) and Rachel and Moshe (siblings and Cleopas’s young neighbours) – as his travelling companions. Cleopas and Miriam are grieving after Yeshua’s crucifixion (Jesus is called by his Hebrew name ‘Yeshua’ in this book) and afraid that they might meet a similar fate. So when a stranger joins their group and offers to narrate stories to while away the time during the long walk ahead, they readily accept, not knowing that he was the very person they believed dead: the resurrected Lord Jesus in the flesh. The Bible never clarifies what Jesus spoke to Cleopas and his companion disciple on the way to Emmaus. So the author has used his creativity to fill in the gaps. And when I say “creativity”, I mean it in the true sense of the word. Yeshua’s narratives and Cleopas and Mary’s discussions bring about a thought-provoking correlation between the stories of the Old Testament and the New Testament. I loved how each of them took a story from one of the Testaments and found a convincing parallel to it in the other Testament. This means that the stories don’t necessarily proceed in chronological Biblical order, but in an order that makes the comparison more feasible: in terms of shared traits with the life of Jesus. Having two child characters makes a big difference to the storytelling. Rachel and Moshe ask several questions to the “teacher”, which helps us also understand the stories better. There is plenty of humour injected into the narrative, part of which comes through Moshe’s constant references to food. While the core essence of the content remains biblical, the language is suitably adapted for modern readers. Moshe especially has vocabulary that suits his age. The new, simpler rendition of the Ten Commandments is truly easy for kids to understand. That said, the modified version of The Lord’s Prayer was a little too novel for me. The parallel storytelling is a clever way of revealing the commonalities between some events of both the testaments. However, no matter how creative, the correlation between the Old Testament and the New Testament needs a certain familiarity with basic biblical stories. The lack of a linear narrative adds to the difficulty of comprehension. Moreover, I felt that the continuity of the panels was a bit off at times. As such, younger children might find the content a bit complicated to understand. As much as I enjoyed the innovative approach to the story of Jesus, I loved the illustrations even more. The graphics are in digital art with full colour throughout. The flashback scenes come in a different colour scheme, thereby making it somewhat easier to follow the multi-thread narrative. The skin tones and eye colours were racially authentic – no enforced white skin and blue eyes here! Everyone is justifiably Middle-Eastern in appearance. The character features are also suitably rustic instead of catering to modern beauty standards of delicate features and dainty noses. Even the angels aren’t sketched with the standard western “golden blonde” look. I am so used to seeing Mother Mary in blue that seeing her in red garments took some adjusting, but I loved that creative call. The graphic personification of the Word of God was outstanding. A shoutout to that stunning cover with Jesus laughing heartily – I loved it! Books rarely depict this side of Jesus’s personality. All in all, I loved the creativity of the concept and the illustrations. The execution is also great, but I think it might be a tad complex for younger readers. Adult guidance ought to help. As current times clearly prove, those indulging in the loudest Bible-thumping are the ones who know least about what’s actually advocated in the Bible. Perhaps this graphic novel would also be a quick way for such ignoramuses to learn the true teachings of God. (Oh, and just so you know, the graphic novel makes the biblical position on women as well as immigrants absolutely clear. And no, it’s not what the current “ruler” of the USA and his stooges want you to believe.) Definitely recommended to anyone looking to read unusually-structured biblical stories in a graphic-novel format. This book would make a great gift, especially on special occasions such as Easter, confirmation and so on. The official target audience for this book is middle-graders, but it works even better for older readers. 4 stars. My thanks to WaterBrook & Multnomah for providing the DRC of “God with Us: Bible Stories on the Road to Emmaus” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 24, 2025
|
Feb 09, 2025
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1960171240
| 9781960171245
| 1960171240
| 4.50
| 661
| Aug 21, 2024
| Aug 12, 2025
|
it was amazing
|
In a Nutshell: What an adorable graphic novel! Three quirky stories within one book. Each has ‘happy endings’, and even better is the entertaining jou
In a Nutshell: What an adorable graphic novel! Three quirky stories within one book. Each has ‘happy endings’, and even better is the entertaining journey to these endings. Loved this! Much recommended! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This graphic novel was originally published in French under the same title in August 2024. This is the English translation, coming out in April 2025. The cover of the English edition appears to have a different vibe from that of the French edition. [image] [image] English Edition ------- French Edition I read on the author’s Instagram page that the second cover under the dust jacket will be the same as what we see on the French edition. However, I like the English cover better. There is something absurdly hilarious about seeing two such stiff-looking agents in formal wear standing against such a pastel pink background, and holding a cat to boot! ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 11, 2025
|
Feb 13, 2025
|
Feb 01, 2025
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
199834102X
| 9781998341023
| 199834102X
| 4.63
| 129
| Nov 25, 2025
| Nov 25, 2025
|
it was amazing
|
Finally, an update on Volume 5!! That cover is swoonworthy!
|
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Jan 27, 2025
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
0593182308
| 9780593182307
| 0593182308
| 4.38
| 861
| Mar 04, 2025
| Mar 04, 2025
|
liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade fantasy in graphic novel form. Excellent illustrations. Good potential in the story, but leaves a lot of things half-bak
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade fantasy in graphic novel form. Excellent illustrations. Good potential in the story, but leaves a lot of things half-baked. Might work better for young adults than middle-graders. Mine is an outlier review. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: Rowan is a trainee ranger, protecting the area under them with the help of their Pegasus, Kestrel. The region Rowan monitors hardly has any danger, much to Rowan’s frustration. The only person active and about in the area is Leone, a laidback shepherd who is more interested in playing his violin than in watching his sheep. However, when Rowan’s eagerness to prove their capabilities to the senior rangers results in an injury to Kestrel, Rowan is forced to work on land-based duties with Leone. Can this forced working partnership turn into friendship when both Rowan and Leone are battling personal secrets? The official blurb gives me a strong YA vibe. However, this is a middle-grade fantasy, and that stumps me a bit. Nothing about the story or the writing approach screams “middle-grade.” (I am not saying this because of the gender dysphoria; that’s a welcome topic in any book.) The blurb clearly hints at Rowan, the main character, using the they/them pronouns. However, for almost the entire book, we see Rowan referred to by their birth name “Rose” and feminine pronouns. So either that the blurb leaked out a big spoiler about the lead character’s identity conflict, or that the blurb was deliberately misleading. Whatever the reason, this early reveal of a later plot point left me dissatisfied as I learnt the source of Rowan’s struggle even before it was brought up in the story. I love the existence of a gender identity conflict in a middle-grade work, but I wish Rowan’s struggle hadn’t been restricted to thoughts alone. Their conundrums should have been indicated more strongly on paper. After a point, it was clear that they wished to be known as Rowan, but the transition is almost instant in the story. No clarifications, no contradictions, no questioning. Real life isn't that easy for LGBTQ+ people! This problem of raising issues in a undeveloped manner is persistent throughout the book. A lot of the conflict is only internalised, without letting us know why or how or what next. Leone’s secret passion gets a tiny mention in a verbal flashback reference; Rowan’s background isn't even brought up. It is tougher to invest in a character we don’t have a backstory for. The rest of the characters are also inadequately sketched. We get to see who they are at that point of the story, but there’s nothing to make us actually know or understand them or their behaviour. This applies even to Leone, who is only somewhat defined despite being Rowan’s co-lead. There are hardly any parents in the book, which means that the primary relationships are either peers (Rowan’s fellow rangers – a motley group), teachers (the senior rangers; wish some of them had a greater role to play), and local villagers (hardly any substantial depiction.) The ages of the characters are never clarified, but I presume Rowan and Leone to be teens. The only character I absolutely loved was Kestrel, Rowan’s Pegasus. She had strength, courage, grace, and even a temper, making her an ideal animal companion for a fictional work. The plot itself is decent as far as the rangers’ work-related content goes. But the worldbuilding is utterly vague. The locations are there but I couldn’t *feel* any of them. A good middle-grade book has a strong and well-defined ending, but this one goofs up even on that. The overall story is divided into chapter-like parts, but the last part comes after a time-jump of unknown duration. We see some of the final developments through the illustrations, but almost everything that’s important is left unsaid. The illustrations are great, probably the best feature of the book. Though not as ethereal as in ‘The Moth Keeper’, the colour scheme, the animals (especially the various Pegasuses) and the nature scenes are all a delight. Quite a few pages have no text bubbles, so this 240-page graphic novel goes by even faster. But this further highlights the issue I had – the text was given much lower priority. As such, the plot feels surface-level and rushed. There are some good life lessons here, most of which could be valuable for the target readers. No need to focus only on proving yourself to others, live for yourself and not by others’ standards, think before you act, try to ignore judgement, and do what your heart wants – worthy points, all. Overall, this book was mostly vague in its character development and jumpy in its plot development. I have read this author’s ‘The Moth Keeper’ and really loved it. Thereby, my expectations from this work were quite high. The execution though left me mostly disappointed. However, the ratings clearly prove that mine is an outlier opinion. So please do take a look through other opinions and take a more informed call on this work. Recommended mainly to those who read graphic novels for illustrations. With the story being so vague about ages and backgrounds, I think this might work better for older teens/YAs than middle-graders, but the official target age is 10+. 2.5 stars, rounding up for the theme and the illustrations. My thanks to A Song for You and I for providing the DRC of “A Song for You and I” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. Sorry this didn’t work out better. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Mar 04, 2025
|
Mar 11, 2025
|
Jan 09, 2025
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
194780832X
| 9781947808324
| 194780832X
| 3.89
| 169
| unknown
| Jan 21, 2025
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A wonderful option for manga lovers to experience Arthur Conan Doyle’s ‘A Study in Scarlet’. Faithful to the original. Full-colour grap
In a Nutshell: A wonderful option for manga lovers to experience Arthur Conan Doyle’s ‘A Study in Scarlet’. Faithful to the original. Full-colour graphics. Sherlock and Watson look too young to be convincing, but the rest is great. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: The same story as ‘A Study in Scarlet’, the very first novel where ace detective Sherlock Holmes makes his appearance. This manga is faithful to the classic in every relevant way, skipping out only a few of the relatively unimportant scenes. Let me again begin by reminding manga newbies that this book is almost in traditional manga format, with the reverse right-to-left pattern of storyboarding. ‘Almost’ because unlike most manga, this is in full colour. ‘A Study in Scarlet’ is the first of the four Sherlock Holmes novels (The rest of his detective outings are in short stories.) While it is not my favourite of the Holmes books (That honour belongs to the incomparable ‘The Hound of the Baskervilles’!), I still like this book for the way it introduced the characters of Holmes and Watson to readers. Without feeling too much like an ‘origin story’, it still offered us a well-rounded insight of the two characters such that we get a handle of their personalities before the actual case begins. This is something Christie failed to do for both Poirot and Marple in their respective first appearances. I have read a few Manga Classics by now, and I have found them mostly faithful to the original works. (This also goes against them when it comes to manga adaptations of Shakespeare, but that’s a story for another day.) This book is no exception. The plotline is true to the original novel in all essential aspects. If you have read ‘A Study in Scarlet’, you might remember that the story has two distinct halves. I wasn’t a fan of this decision as I was caught by surprise at the change in tone, setting, and characters for the second half of the story. It took me a long time to understand where Doyle was going with the whole thing. The segue between the two sections had been too abrupt. This manga rectifies the issue wonderfully. I can’t tell you how as it would be a spoiler, but suffice it to say, the story no longer feels like two distinct halves forcibly joined together. The illustrations serve the story decently well. The actions and the emotions are spot on. I appreciate how characters were introduced with little text boxes containing their name – very helpful for a book with many characters. I especially enjoyed the depiction of Sherlock’s street squad: the Baker Street Boys. Their street-urchin charm and attitude were captured perfectly. I wish the art had got the portrayal right for some characters. Manga Sherlock certainly looks hot, but he doesn’t look “Sherlock-y’. Sherlock is supposed to be about 26-27 in the first book, so he does look his age. But John Watson looks like a college boy with his fresh face, not like an experienced army doctor straight out from Afghanistan. For some reason, I got this weird feeling that Sherlock and John were being set up as a potential romantic pair (‘shipped’, as youngsters say) in the artwork. Stamford, who is supposed to be Watson’s batchmate, looks like his grandpa. I am not sure if the “maid” in the story was supposed to be Mrs. Hudson, but if yes, she also was sketched too youthfully to be a middle-aged housekeeper. Other than the issues with the art, I have no grouses with the story. I love it when adaptations stay true to the original, and this one certainly does. It would be a great way for manga lovers to experience the brilliance of Sherlock Holmes without having to wade through the descriptive text of the original. Definitely recommended to manga fans and Sherlock fans. 4.25 stars. My thanks to Udon Entertainment for providing the DRC of “Manga Classics: Sherlock Holmes Vol. 1 - A Study in Scarlet” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Dec 30, 2024
|
Jan 06, 2025
|
Dec 30, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
163715612X
| 9781637156124
| 163715612X
| 3.87
| 399
| Feb 25, 2025
| Feb 25, 2025
|
it was ok
|
In a Nutshell: A scifi action graphic novel about a comic artist fighting an alien invasion. Wacky characters and wildly adventurous storytelling. Wor
In a Nutshell: A scifi action graphic novel about a comic artist fighting an alien invasion. Wacky characters and wildly adventurous storytelling. Works in bits and pieces, but doesn’t come together in a cohesive whole. This is partly because the story went in a direction I don’t prefer reading. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: Maya is a comic book artist frustrated about deadlines and about not doing the kind of comics she loves. Her best friend Juu is also frustrated, but with his lacklustre love life. This graphic novel was originally published in 2023 under the same title in Spanish (Castilian). This English translation is due to be published in February 2025. If I have to use one word to describe this entire reading experience, it would probably be “quirky.” From the characters to the plotline, there’s nothing ordinary about this story. But this isn't necessarily a good thing. The quirkiness is as much a strength as a weakness of the book. Maya is an interesting character. It was fun to see her channelize her frustration with her work into anger against the invading aliens. Soma is a great extra-terrestrial addition to the plot. (Note that his name is revealed only after the 80% mark, which is quite strange considering the book is named after him. Even the blurb mentions his name clearly.) Juu is quite weird at first, and it is good to see him gain courage as the story progresses. However, if we strictly think about it, his arc isn’t vital to the main story at all, so he feels like a page filler at times. In addition to these three characters, there are also a few secondary characters who shine in their limited roles. That said, I couldn’t really get a clear idea of why most of the characters behaved the way they did. The storyline of the book is good, not great. The alien invasion trope is fairly common in comics. The only differentiating factor here is the type of attack and the counterattack. I like the imaginativeness of the “weapon” that worked against the invaders. There are also some comic scenes to lighten the proceedings. However, I am not that big a reader of action-adventure kind of storylines, so the moment this book diverged into that kind of narrative, I lost my interest. I might not have opted for this graphic novel had I known that at least a third of the book would involve action sequences. (The English cover simply doesn’t indicate that this would go into an actual Hollywood-style alien attack. ☹ The Spanish cover is more accurate in that respect, but I didn’t see it before getting the book.) The plot is fairly fast-paced. It is divided into three distinct parts – before, during, and after the invasion. The Before section is quite interesting, but there’s a sudden segue into the actual invasion, during which things feel somewhat repetitive and chaotic. The invasion scenes could have benefited with some more detailing. The attack feels too rushed: nothing in one scene and total destruction in the next. The After section is decent, but again, it feels abrupt and too quiet after all the noise of the invasion pages. The whole book reads like a children’s novel with an overly straightforward plot. But it is actually meant for adults, which leaves me slightly conflicted about how well it will work with the actual target audience. The illustrations are decent but somewhat cluttered. There’s a lot happening on some pages, which ends up bombarding the eyes with an illustrative overload. Plus, the “invasion” pages are red-dominant, which saturates the eyes sooner. The scenes in the alien spaceships aren’t so clear in plot. The “snot dripping from the nose” expression is a bit too repetitive. That said, I love that the speech bubbles have coloured backgrounds to denote which character is speaking – a great idea. All in all, not a bad story, but perhaps not a great option for adult graphic novel readers. The storyline is way too simplistic and rushed for adults. However, it might work better for teens and young adults. It might also click with those who enjoy action-adventure comics. Not my cuppa tea, though. 2 stars. My thanks to Oni Press for providing the DRC of “Soma” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. Sorry this didn’t work out better. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 13, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Dec 28, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
B0DVB2ZR7W
| 4.45
| 91
| unknown
| unknown
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A loveable webcomic about a (now) friendly vampire and his attempts at fitting in the human world. Gruesome and/or sad at times, but mo
In a Nutshell: A loveable webcomic about a (now) friendly vampire and his attempts at fitting in the human world. Gruesome and/or sad at times, but mostly heartwarming. Free for all to read on the author’s site, but it is incomplete and there’s not much hope of its getting an ending anytime soon. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: The fact that Patrik is a vampire often comes in the way of his making friends. But he hasn't stopped trying. While he does have his demons (mostly figurative, but one actual), he is still an amiable fellow who enjoys helping others. If only they could see beyond his fangs and his compulsive need for blood! I am not one for vampire stories, whether horror or comic. But I have wanted to try this webcomic ever since I read this author’s ‘Garlic and the Vampire’ graphic novel series, which also features an amazing vampire. In many ways, this is a typical vampire story. There are scenes of murder, vampire bites, fear, humans being “turned” into vampires… But the story goes much beyond the typical tropes, and even avoids the sillier ones such as vampires turning into bats or sleeping in coffins. As we see Patrik’s life story in multiple centuries, we see various aspects to his “ordinary life” that wouldn’t be present in a typical Nosferatu tale. The multiple timelines are a masterstroke. Seeing Patrik in 1929 as well as 2012 means we get to see similarities and differences in his behaviour after the gap of a century. The contemporary timeline was especially fun because it felt so odd to see a vampire visiting a cafe so casually. There are also other timelines, but these are far and few between, and serve only to provide a further background to Patrik’s past life when needed. Don’t let the tomfoolery let you forget that you are reading a vampire story. The content gets very dark on a few pages. There are also many scenes that could be emotionally upsetting. But all this is to be expected if a vampire story has to feel realistic. (“Vampire story - feel realistic” – Hah!) Patrik is one heck of a character. He is funny, caring, and helpful, but he also suffers from nightmares and guilt because of his past. You can actually feel his loneliness in the initial pages. I found it very interesting that he was fairly open about being a vampire, and most of those who knew about it were accepting of his identity… well… to whatever extent it was possible to be accepting without being 100% trusting. The other characters are also amazing. Becky from the 2012 was my favourite. Just a teenage/young adult, she is still the coolest of Patrik’s acquaintances, and probably the only one who accepts his friendship without any hesitation, doubt, or selfish requirement. I simply loved her, though I did want to shake her at times for her naivete. Patrik’s neighbours from the 1929 timeline, Lara and her grandmother, are sketched more realistically, with grandma being the typical loveable granny and Lara being sceptical of Patrik’s every word and action. Other than these key characters, we have Cyril the demon (who is so unlike a demon in appearance that his identity came as a shock to me!) and Fifi the Persian cat (loved her equation – or lack thereof – with Patrik.) The graphics are adorable and enjoyable, if you are used to the author’s quirky illustrative style. The various timelines are sketches in a subtly different colour tone. The 1929 timeline is somewhat dullish in colour, like an old Eastman colour movie, where the 2012 storyline comes in hues as bright and peppy as Becky. The speech bubbles come with varied background colours that give a cue of who is speaking. There’s also an interesting way of depicting the conversations that are in Romanian. The whole graphic experience is very reader-friendly. The only hurdle in a greater enjoyment of this book is that it is incomplete. The author had invested more than eight years in the making of this weekly webcomic, and towards the last couple of years, she began losing the joy of adding to Patrik’s story. As of today, this book remains on an “indefinite hiatus”. It must be very tough to give up on a character because of whom her art became well-known, but I do understand how eight years of drawing the same characters can become tedious. To be frank, the extensive duration shows in the plot development, as it can be quite random at times. This isn't strictly a negative as it gives the webcomic a more episodic feel, but it indicates that the comic was started without an endpoint in mind. Fingers crossed that the author will complete Patrik’s story someday, but either way, I am grateful that she invested so many years into creating this memorable, one-of-a-kind comic. 4.25 stars. If you are interested in reading this atypical vampire story and don’t mind an incomplete experience, you can read this webcomic for free on the author’s site using the below link: https://www.patrikthevampire.com/comi... Don’t be unnerved by the 473 pages count. It goes by quite quickly. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Dec 2024
|
Dec 03, 2024
|
Dec 01, 2024
|
ebook
| |||||||||||||||||
0062351257
| 9780062351258
| 0062351257
| 4.27
| 165
| unknown
| Apr 05, 2022
|
it was amazing
|
In a Nutshell: The third book of the Arlo & Pips early-reader chapter book series. The story, the wit, the trivia, and the illustrations come together
In a Nutshell: The third book of the Arlo & Pips early-reader chapter book series. The story, the wit, the trivia, and the illustrations come together in one adorable package. My favourite book of this series. What a wonderful finale! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Arlo and Marla are now together. Their love has been… errrmm… fruitful, and there are... literally… new kids As is clear, this series is progressing though Arlo’s life sequentially. From a young crow in the first book to a chap in love in the next one, Arlo is now a responsible parent. Don’t for a second imagine that this indicates a stop to his bragging! Au contraire, it only means that he has new points to brag about. This time though, he cannot be blamed as every parent loves to brag about their children. Pips is, as usual, my favourite character. I simply love the way he stands by his friend even as he is rolling his eyes over Arlo’s tall claims. He sets a great example of responsible friendship. Thanks to the young brood, we get plenty of facts related to baby crows and even the parenting habits of adult crows. The facts come out through the story as well as the ever-present footnotes. The illustrations are in the same style as the other books of this series: simple but highly effective. While I enjoyed the earlier books as well, this book was easily my favourite. I am not sure if it was because of the parenting-related storyline or the humour, but somehow, this book was a notch above the rest. All three books have been funny as well as informative. (Except on one factor: I still don’t know what kind of bird Pips is!) My heart bids a fond adieu to this series. It's been great learning more about my favourite corvid courtesy Arlo. Much recommended, both for the humour and for the trivia. I am sure kids will enjoy all three books. 4.5 stars, happy to round up! This was borrowed from my library. Book 1: King of the Birds Book 2: Join the Crow Crowd ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 28, 2024
|
Dec 2024
|
Nov 28, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1638991391
| 9781638991397
| 1638991391
| 4.03
| 39
| 2017
| Mar 18, 2025
|
liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A graphic novel about a pregnant girl who feels alone in the world. Good use of the 1970s historical setting and the Florida Keys locat
In a Nutshell: A graphic novel about a pregnant girl who feels alone in the world. Good use of the 1970s historical setting and the Florida Keys location. Somewhat literary in style, complex characters, slightly unstructured plot, no closure at the end, old-style illustrations. This is for those who are more about the journey than about the destination. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: 1976. Greer Johnson is pregnant with her boss’s baby. At his insistence, she is forced to move from Miami to Florida to stay with his acquaintances, Donald and Kate Bender. The Benders, an old childless couple, have their own reasons for allowing Greer into their house. However, their constant interference bothers Greer, and she longs for someone to understand her. With only a Cuban immigrant gardener around, Greer resorts to flights of fancy to save herself from the dreary days. But will her imagination be enough to improve her reality? While reading the synopsis of this novel, the historical fiction fan in me became quite curious. The trope of a single pregnant girl being sent to Florida isn't new to historical fiction readers. However, most such books involve the use of “maternity homes”, where the unwed girls were kept till their delivery and their babies would then be offered for adoption while the girls returned to their pre-pregnancy carefree(?) life. This graphic novel surprised me by not having a maternity home at all. Greer was at a private residence, and absolutely free to move about town. So it certainly wasn’t the kind of story I thought I was getting. Greer’s stay at the Bender residence carries different complications. As Donald Bender doesn’t have a lengthy role, the main conflict of the plot comes from the tussle between Greer and Kate. Given their circumstances and interactions, it is quite tough to decide whom to root for. You might assume that it is obvious to have sympathies towards the pregnant protagonist, but Greer’s behaviour is such that in some scenes, Kate’s frustration reflects our frustration. Many of Greer’s decisions spring from naivete and selfishness, while Kate’s responses come from age-domination and stubbornness. Basically, this isn't a book for those who want likeable characters. Except for Pablo the Cuban gardener (who is a bit too perfect to be convincing in a book wherever everyone else is flawed), the characters are mostly grey and annoying. There are three subplots in this book. One is, of course, Greer’s life, covering her stay at the Benders’ place and her musings over her future. The second arc is connected to Greer’s imaginative tendencies, which make her create a story about a little girl named Eugenie. The scenes related to Eugenie were quite sweet to read, though they too contained moments of pain. A part of me enjoyed Eugenie’s story much more than Greer’s story. The final arc is about Greer’s past memories, mainly focussing on her late mother and on her old friend named Chris. These left me conflicted as they raised several issues without sorting any properly. The main reason I couldn’t connect with Greer is that, while her past is explained to some extent, her present decisions don’t come out that clearly. What exactly led to the dalliance between her boss and her, and was it even a dalliance or rape by deception, we never know. Several other life choices she makes are also not elucidated well. The reasons for Kate’s almost-bipolar behaviour are also not explained properly. I would have liked the story far better if I were able to get a clear handle on the characters’ motives and actions. The title seems to indicate a positive storyline, but the book is rarely positive. With several heavy themes such as closeted attitudes about pre-marital pregnancy, enforced Christian beliefs, mental health issues, self-harming, body image issues, childlessness, illegal immigration, and loneliness, the book felt overloaded with issues. Some scenes showed televised news or a radio broadcast running in the background, and these added even more socio-political topics connected to the news of the day. As such, this book doesn’t make for easy reading at all. The action of “flying away” indicated in the title is metaphorical for the most way, in terms of how Greer flies away in her imagination. The ending gives a more literal tone to the same, but it offers no closure by leaving the future uncertain. The illustrations are like nothing I have seen before. This kind of artwork worked both for and against the book. It is quite vintage in style, so reading the book often felt like reading an old comic. As can be seen from the cover page, the book is landscape in orientation, which also adds to the novelty of the experience. I took some time adjusting to the darkish colour tone that used mostly browns and greens. But once my eyes got used to the palette, I enjoyed the illustrations. I even liked that the three subplots each had a distinct colour scheme; it made things easier to understand, especially as no timelines were given and hence flashbacks could turn confusing. Many pages had only graphics and no text, but the panels on these contained several intricate detailing, where the character’s emotions, left not just unspoken but also unexplained, weren’t always easy to interpret. As such, this 410+ pages novel needs concentration. All in all, this is a very literary kind of graphic novel, with a strong character-oriented plot that doesn’t explain much. You might consider it a clever book that reveals only the characters’ actions and allows you to make up your own mind about them. But if you are the type of reader who prefers all i's dotted and t’s crossed, you might find this book a bit frustrating. Recommended to those who enjoy the journey of a story more than its destination, and who value the art of a graphic novel more than its plot. I like the destination as much as the journey, and I prefer a balance between plot and art no matter how well either factor works individually. Thus, this book just hits the midway mark for me. 3 stars. My thanks to Iron Circus Comics for providing the DRC of “The Girl Who Flew Away” via Edelweiss+. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Threads || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 2025
|
Feb 08, 2025
|
Nov 28, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
0062394231
| 9780062394231
| 0062394231
| 4.26
| 257
| unknown
| Aug 17, 2021
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: The second book of the Arlo & Pips early-reader chapter book series. Continues the fun from the first book with the same adorable chara
In a Nutshell: The second book of the Arlo & Pips early-reader chapter book series. Continues the fun from the first book with the same adorable characters. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Arlo has now settled in the city, but he is lonely. When he confesses to Pips that he doesn’t have any other crow friends, Pips takes him to a park where a ‘murder’ resides. Arlo learns that there are others crows cleverer than him, and even meets the love of his life. ( ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 25, 2024
|
Nov 28, 2024
|
Nov 25, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0062982214
| 9780062982216
| 0062982214
| 4.29
| 754
| Oct 06, 2020
| Oct 06, 2020
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A cute early-reader graphic novel with two birds in the lead, one of whom is a tad too vain. Plenty of fun, plenty of fun facts. Much r
In a Nutshell: A cute early-reader graphic novel with two birds in the lead, one of whom is a tad too vain. Plenty of fun, plenty of fun facts. Much recommended! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Arlo the crow has just moved from the country to a big city. As he meets a new bird named Pips (I couldn’t figure out what species Pips belonged to!), Arlo begins bragging about … well… everything! His ramp-worthy looks, his singing talent, his genius brain, his shiny-things collection… You name it, Arlo flaunts it! Pips is sceptical about Arlo’s claims, but he soon learns that Arlo does have quite a few amazing skills. If only he weren’t so boastful about them! The story is presented in the form of three interlinked chapters that reveal the personality of the two characters wonderfully. Each story takes the new “friendship” a step ahead. While it is tough to like a pompous character, Arlo endears himself to us – this is a big achievement on the author’s part. He's quite a braggart (to put it mildly), but he also goes to prove his claims with concrete action. (Funnily, most of the claims do turn out to be true. No comments on the singing skills, though!) Both the main characters are well developed. Arlo is supremely confident in his position, but little Pips won my heart more. Throughout the story, he is a patient, wise, and helpful friend who doesn’t hesitate to stop Arlo when the bragging goes too far. (See how he is yelling at Arlo on the cover – hilarious!) I’d love to see how their friendship progresses in the remaining two books of this series. The book smartly uses Arlo’s boasts to present several fabulous facts about crows via footnotes. Every footnote is indicated by a bright red star and written neatly at the bottom of the page, making it easy for little eyes to spot. I am usually ambiguous about footnotes, but in this case, I think the author has put footnotes to excellent use. Such an innovative way of learning more about a bird that's often ignored! I love crows so it did my heart happy to see a book celebrate them in such a unique manner. The illustrations are equally adorable. As is needed with such books, the graphics are kept simple. The animals are sketched in a cute manner, and the typeface is also appropriate for kids. I loved the little onomatopoeic add-ons on a few pages. The colours are limited to the basic primary set and there’s no shading or shadowing, thereby limiting distractions and keeping the focus on the characters, their expressions, and the storyline. The only, and I do mean ONLY, thing I would have changed about the book would be to make Arlo realise that he shouldn’t be so vain. It’s good to be good at something, but making sure the whole world knows the same? Not sure if I want kids to inculcate that habit! I hope kids listen to Pips and his wise advice about vanity not being a good trait. All in all, this is a fabulous story that presents an ode to crows through the character of a crow who is presenting an ode to himself. (That sentence went a bit meta! ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 25, 2024
|
Nov 25, 2024
|
Nov 25, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1958325163
| 9781958325162
| 1958325163
| 4.30
| 37
| unknown
| Oct 01, 2024
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: The third standalone graphic novel in the Penguin and Panda series. The best of the series so far, with wonderful wintry vibes. ~~~~~~~~ In a Nutshell: The third standalone graphic novel in the Penguin and Panda series. The best of the series so far, with wonderful wintry vibes. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This cute graphic novel is about two best friends and their adventures together. This is the third book in the ‘Adventures of Penguin and Panda’ series, but the books are standalone and can be read in any order. (That said, if you begin with this book, you might be befuddled about why Panda is carrying around an egg named Fred; he first popped up in the second book and evidently hasn’t popped out yet.) The format of this book is the same as the other books in the series. There are four independent stories featuring the two titular animals and their adventures. As the title indicates, the dominant theme in this book is winter, so we get loads of snow and wintry vibes, along with a dash of Christmas. Panda’s need for naps is still quite strong. Penguin is still her careful self, though the third story shows that she can also be adventurous in her choices when it suits her. I love how well the personalities of these two have been created and maintained consistently throughout the series. This book also contains several fun facts about penguins and pandas. The text is quite simple for the target age group, and the illustrations also, with their bright pastels and simple lines, would work wonderfully for them. Not sure if it is because of the upcoming Christmas season, but this ended up my favourite of the three Penguin and Panda books I’ve read so far. All the stories were great, and all the life lessons were fun. Definitely recommended! This would be a wonderful Christmas gift for kids aged 4-8. 4.25 stars. My thanks to Marble Press for providing the DRC of “The Adventures of Penguin and Panda: Winterfest” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 19, 2024
|
Nov 19, 2024
|
Nov 19, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1958325058
| 9781958325056
| 1958325058
| 4.33
| 51
| Apr 30, 2024
| Apr 30, 2024
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: The first standalone graphic novel in the Penguin and Panda series. Loveable main characters, sweet stories with good learnings. A nice
In a Nutshell: The first standalone graphic novel in the Penguin and Panda series. Loveable main characters, sweet stories with good learnings. A nice option for beginner readers. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This graphic novel is about two best friends and their adventures together. The book contains four little stories with the two main characters. As the tagline indicates, all four stories have some element of surprise, whether through a game or an outing or a party. While the stories themselves are entertaining, I also liked how they teach important values without shoving them into children’s faces. Subtle behavioural tactics such as listening to your friend or doing nice things for others unconditionally come out better through examples than advice. Panda and Penguin make for a loveable duo. Panda is too easygoing while Penguin is slightly more fussy about her needs. This makes their friendship a mutually beneficial one, as they each learn from the other. This book also contains some fun penguin and panda related jokes, a how to draw section, and some fun facts about the two animals. All in all, this is a good option for little ones who enjoy comic-style stories with loveable characters. The life lessons are a bonus. This is the first book in the ‘Adventures of Penguin and Panda’ series, but the books are standalone and can be read in any order. 3.75 stars. My thanks to Marble Press for allowing access to the DRC of “The Adventures of Penguin and Panda: Surprise!” via Edelweiss+. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Oct 20, 2024
|
Oct 20, 2024
|
Oct 20, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
9798888772928
| B0CVKXR7WJ
| 4.25
| 1,078
| unknown
| Nov 12, 2024
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A manga about a geeky IT guy who discovers love right next door during the lockdown. A sweet and funny story, though it takes too long
In a Nutshell: A manga about a geeky IT guy who discovers love right next door during the lockdown. A sweet and funny story, though it takes too long to get going. The flashback-style narration also doesn’t do it any favours. But a good option for those wanting a light-hearted opposites-attract love story. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: When Nokoru is told to telework from home during the pandemic lockdown, he views it as a blessing. His job as a system engineer is very demanding, especially because of clientele who don’t know what they want. Working from home comes with unexpected benefits, such as getting to wake up just ten minutes before work, or managing to find more time for hobbies such as gardening and gaming. What Nokoru doesn’t expect is to interact over his balcony with his new neighbour right next door. Natsu, a graduate student of archaeology, is everything Nokoru is not: impulsive, relaxed, chaotic, gorgeous, always smiling! Is there any hope for a relationship between such disparate souls, especially when social distancing is de rigueur? This manga is the first standalone book by this author, which he has expanded from a one-shot story about two characters working at home during the pandemic. This manga is written in the traditional format, with a right-to-left story flow and B&W illustrations. (Making this explicitly clear for those who aren’t used to manga but might be tempted by the cute cover and premise.) Nokoru is a fantastic character, though it takes time for him to grow on the reader. He comes across as extremely formal, even in dating and love. Always logical and disciplined in his approach towards everything, Nokoru can’t seem to do anything impulsively. He is also an overthinker, which leads to his questioning and analysing every single word and action Natsu makes. This leads to a lot of rambling thoughts, which can be either hilarious or annoying, depending on your mood. I have rarely seen a male character depicted with so many inner monologues! Luckily for him, I was in a good mood while reading this. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Dec 17, 2024
|
Dec 20, 2024
|
Oct 19, 2024
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||
0063011085
| 9780063011083
| 0063011085
| 4.38
| 437
| Nov 12, 2024
| Nov 12, 2024
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade graphic novel written in verse, telling the story of two tweens from North Korea and their planned escape to a brighter
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade graphic novel written in verse, telling the story of two tweens from North Korea and their planned escape to a brighter future. I wanted to like this far more than I did, but a few of the writing choices didn’t work for me. The illustrations are stunning. The book has some dark content, so it would be better if adults read and evaluate its suitability for their kids before handing it over. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: 2013, North Korea. Yunho is a shy ten-year-old who stays alone with his grandmother after his mother escaped across the border to China to earn money and improve their circumstances. She had promised to send for Yunho as soon as possible, but it has been almost two years now with no update. Yunho is good at finding scrap metal, which he sells to the government in exchange for some much-needed money. A book based on two young children fending for themselves in the totalitarian regime of North Korea has to have tremendous merit. Through this graphic novel, we get a glimpse of how rigid the governmental regulations are, how tough it is for the less-fortunate citizens of the country to survive, and how little the residents can trust anyone around them for fear of being reported, or worse, killed. Most of us don’t know much about life in that closed dictatorship, so this book offers a gritty look at the situation there. The plot captures the restrictive atmosphere and the fear of the people perfectly. It also depicts the citizens’ external subservience to the regime’s dictates, even if they believe something else within. It is easy for us outsiders to question why these people are blind to their woes and why they don’t protest or overthrow the dictators, but only if we ourselves were in that position would we be able to accept that sometimes, surviving means compromising on many accounts, including rebellious tendencies and ethics. If nothing else, the story generates a sense of gratitude for our privileged life, and makes us appreciative of the freedom we take for granted. While opting for this graphic novel, I hadn’t realised that it was written in verse. I am not comfortable with poetry in any form, so I read the text as ordinary prose and it worked well enough for me. I did see glimpses of a poetic writing style, with some words strung together in a harmonious repetition to deliver a greater impact. Beyond this, I have no comment to make on the poetic merit of this work. That said, the ‘verse’ factor might work against the book; not many readers, regardless of age group, readily opt for books written in verse. The story journeys through five countries, just like our main characters do. The first part, set in North Korea, is the lengthiest and the most impactful. The middle three sections (covering China, Laos, and Thailand) are good but not extensive. The plot feels somewhat rushed here. The final section is based in the USA, the weakest subset of the book. I am familiar with Southeast Asia, so it was easy for me to keep track of the characters’ escape through multiple countries. But to western readers, including a map might have been helpful. The illustrations are stunning, as can be seen from that gorgeous cover art. The graphics seem to be shaded in a kind of watercolour effect, so the art appears as fluid as the verses. The expressions on the characters’ faces is especially praise-worthy; we can actually feel their emotional vulnerability in many of the panels. A special note at the end provides details on North Korean history – this is brilliant. While the core plot definitely worked for me, some of the writing decisions left me dissatisfied. - I didn’t expect to see strong Christian content in this book. Having a pastor as one of the rescuers meant that some lines were deeply rooted in belief, which was fine. But going much beyond those scenes to establish the power of faith in the Christian God as being essential in their escape? I don’t know how to feel about that. In such a grounded story, adding the faith component wasn’t necessary, even if some refugees would certainly lean on faith to guide them to safety. Considering the universality of the story, I think the book should have focussed more on the practical resilience of the characters than on their spiritual enlightenment. Alternatively, the blurb should have clearly indicated the faith-based content so that readers can take a call with complete information. (Note: Practising Christian here. So no, this feedback has nothing to do with my own faith.) - There are a few scary sequences that might be triggering to sensitive younger readers. I understand that this is based in reality, but a certain dilution of the extreme events such as the public execution would have been better. - Having two POVs in first person is not a great idea for middle-grade books, especially when each perspective lasts barely a couple of pages. The frequent swap in perspective can get confusing. - There is a certain idealisation of asylum life in the USA. The characters seem to get an almost instant resolution for all their needs there, and they don’t face any racial or other discrimination. It is too smooth to be believable. This especially jars when we remember that, though the story is set in 2013, the book is coming out in 2024, and everyone knows what the dominant rhetoric of the upcoming US president is. All in all, I did love the idea behind this story, and I learnt a lot of life in North Korea. I just wish the issues mentioned above had been handled better. Regardless, this is a great option for anyone wanting an OwnVoices middle-grade option about one of the most restrictive countries in the world. Do note that the content gets quite intense at times. Parents/guardians/teachers, please read this book first and judge its suitability for the little ones in your life. 3.75 stars. My thanks to HarperCollins Children's Books and HarperAlley for providing the DRC of “The Other Side of Tomorrow” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 25, 2024
|
Dec 17, 2024
|
Oct 08, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1947627376
| 9781947627376
| 1947627376
| 3.86
| 368
| Sep 01, 2020
| Sep 01, 2020
|
really liked it
|
In a Nutshell:An OwnVoices middle-grade graphic novel narrating the story of “The Dwarf King of Uxmal”, a Mesoamerican myth. Fun story and interesting
In a Nutshell:An OwnVoices middle-grade graphic novel narrating the story of “The Dwarf King of Uxmal”, a Mesoamerican myth. Fun story and interesting characters. Perfect for the age group. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Plot Preview: A thousand years ago in the Yacatan Peninsula, the city of Uxmal was ruled by a cruel king named Kinich Kak Ek. So sure was he of his power that he was unfazed by a prophecy announcing the kind of person who would threaten his throne. Most mythological retellings seem to focus only on Greek or Norse mythology. But there are so many other indigenous cultures around the world that have a rich mythical heritage. This is my first time reading a retelling of a Mesoamerican myth, and I am keen to read more! Author David Bowles has penned a nonfiction book on the myths of Mexico: ‘Feathered Serpent, Dark Heart of Sky: Myths of Mexico.’ For a reason that he beautifully revealed in the author’s note, he has decided to take ten myths from his book and turn them into graphic novels for middle-graders. A brilliant idea, I say! Graphic novels are the best way of grabbing kids’ attention, so this format would certainly appeal to them and also teach them some amazing new indigenous stories. ‘Rise of the Halfling King’ is the first book of this planned series. The story is exactly as you would expect from a children’s adaptation of a mythological story: simple but straightforward storytelling, good vs. bad theme, loads of magic and action, some fun animals, and a scary mythical creature to boot. As the ancient world and its denizens, especially the elfin Aluxes – the wise ancients – might be a bit unfamiliar to most readers, having the Dramatis Personae at the star helps a lot. (Bonus points for not revealing any plot spoilers in this section.) Sayam and his grandmother are both fabulous characters. I love how his grandma doesn’t have just the ‘old dependent woman’ kind of role. She is an active part of Sayam’s learning and of his challenge against Kinich. Their story proves how magic is incomplete without wisdom and guidance. I’ve not often seen mythological stories giving older women such a powerful role in the narrative, so this was wonderful. I also loved the creative choice of making Sayam use modern phrases that not only prove his age as younger than the other characters but also allow little readers to identify better with him. The illustrations are perfect for a middle-grade work. The simple art style brought back memories of childhood days filled with Tinkle and Amar Chitra Katha comics. I loved the characters and the depiction of their emotions. At just 64 pages, the plot doesn’t go too deep, so some of the background details I wanted weren’t available. Then again, there are no loopholes and the story is complete, so children will definitely enjoy it. I’d love to pick up the original nonfiction work and learn more about this amazing mythology. Definitely recommended to tweens and teens interested in reading an uncommon retelling of a Mesoamerican myth. It would also work well for adult readers wanting to test the waters of this mythology, though you must keep in mind that this is a beginner-level story and is written at that level. Looking forward to the rest of this series! 4.25 stars. My thanks to Lee & Low Books and Cinco Punto Press for providing the DRC of “Rise of the Halfling King” via Edelweiss+. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Connect with me through: My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || X/Twitter || Facebook || ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Oct 2024
|
Oct 03, 2024
|
Oct 01, 2024
|
Paperback
|