Donna's Reviews > The Boys in the Boat: Nine Americans and Their Epic Quest for Gold at the 1936 Berlin Olympics

The Boys in the Boat by Daniel James Brown
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
10285365
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: biography
Read 2 times. Last read September 5, 2013.

I don't know why I put off reading this book so long, except I was reading other things. BUT when I went to visit my son, who is the grandson of Joe Rantz and named his son Joe after him, I began reading their copy and could not put it down. Everything else I was reading was put aside.

I then realized I would not finish it before I had to leave and besides, I wanted to OWN it. So I got the Kindle version. Besides, my son was also reading it and we had two book marks, his and mine in the book. So it made things easier.

Wow, I was surprised at all the things I learned about Joe and Joyce I had not known before. I remember holding Joe's Olympic gold medal long ago when I first married his son, the first and last such medal I have ever held. I remember because it made such an impression on me. I remember the talk of the other "boys" and how they got together and I remember being invited to the planting of the tree for Joseph Rantz but did not go. I don't remember why. I have always proudly told everyone that my son's grandfather won an Olympic Gold Medal in Hitler's Germany in 1936. Who else can say that? Not many. But really, I had no idea what was involved in that accomplishment.

But after reading this book I realize how very special those boys were, and how important it was that it all came together, the very special men who all had hard upbringings, who had to scrape and scratch for every morsel they ever got, the now legendary boat maker and the coxswain. It took a very unique mix of ingredients to make that win happen and take home that Gold Medal.

But it had to be told in a way that we could all see it,feel it, get it. And Daniel Brown did just that. He interviewed Joe Rantz months before his death.

I remember a man who was tall, handsome, strong and always willing to help. I remember as a young single mother after I had divorced his son, how very warm and welcoming they were to me and how Joe would not only fix my broken down cars but would show me how he did it.

I remember when he fell from the tree when he was still out there too late in his life, climbing trees and cutting them down. I remember saying to myself, if only I could find a man like him, I would keep him. He was my ideal man but I had no idea how he came to be that man.

So now I know.

Update: Sadly last December 15th 2016 At 1:15 pm Joseph Devon Rantz, great grandson of Joe Rantz, was killed in a car accident riding with his friend who was driving in the pouring rain. The car hydroplaned in the rain crossed the median and hit a utility truck and then the bridge abutment. Both boys were wearing seatbelts but the driver was thrown from the car into Dry Creek. Both boys were killed instantly.
We have had tremendous, kind support from the community. We were devastated and just broken by the loss. He was a good kid, 18 years old in his senior year of high school, a lefty pitcher on the varsity baseball team. We loved him and miss him every day.

867 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Boys in the Boat.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 31, 2013 – Started Reading (Kindle Edition)
August 31, 2013 – Shelved (Kindle Edition)
Started Reading
September 5, 2013 – Finished Reading
September 7, 2013 – Shelved as: biography (Kindle Edition)
September 7, 2013 – Shelved
September 7, 2013 – Shelved as: biography
September 7, 2013 – Finished Reading (Kindle Edition)

Comments Showing 51-82 of 82 (82 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 51: by Emi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emi Yoshida I loved your review, am shattered to read your personal update. I am so very sorry for your loss.


Cecil D'costa Donna - it's a great book and your comment makes a great afterword.. heartbroken by your loss ..


message 53: by Jesse (new) - added it

Jesse So sorry for your loss prayers are with you and your family


Anita Schneider Thank you for sharing. Sorry for your loss. Hugs.


Shanle my deepest condolences about your son. How neat to hear your thoughts on the book being the ex-daughter-in-law. Joe and those boys led incredible lives. Such hard workers and never gave up. We could all learn something from them.


message 57: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John Alexander I know what you mean. My wife gave me this book for Christmas 2013 and I just started it the end of Nov 2020. Once I started it, I couldn't put it down, either. I even started back exercising on my rowing machine, which has been sitting idle for months.


message 58: by A (new) - rated it 5 stars

A ❤️


Sarah ❤️❤️❤️


Donny I loved this book so much and in particular the parts about Joe and his incredible struggle with poverty during the depression and his abandonment by his own father. Your review is beautiful and now I read that you have lost your son. What a tragedy, my heart goes out to you, I am so sorry for your loss.


Blanca Ruiz I just finished reading "The Boys in the Boat". It was wonderful that I came across your book review. Thank you for sharing your family history. It's nice to know that Joe was such a nice man, and that you got to know him so well. I am very sorry for the loss of your grandson.


Dkilwein I just read your review and story. I am so very sorry for your losses, I hope their memories give you peace.


message 63: by Jenny (new)

Jenny Goff The story touched my heart… I learned so much about rowing and history and the conflict with Germany… I’m so sorry to hear about the loss of your grandson… Fortunately your story lives forever. Blessings and prayers for you and your family


message 64: by Katy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Katy Rushing Thank you so much for sharing your experience and sorrow. I appreciate you opening up to us Goodreads members and followers of this story


message 65: by Joy (new) - added it

Joy Gimbel Im so sorry, no mother should outlive her child 🫶


Tammy Loved this book, and admire the work ethic and personal integrity that was so beautifully captured in it. My heart goes out to you on your personal loss - so very hard to lose a child.


message 67: by Jill (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jill Jackson This book lead this Rantz girl all the way from a small town in Michigan to Seattle to visit Joe’s gold medal. I loved learning about this piece of history!


Kelly I am so very sorry for your loss. I just started reading the book and look forward to learning more about your beloved son's grandfather.


Kelly Sorry...beloved grandson's grandfather.


message 70: by Marisela (new) - added it

Marisela My condolences.


message 71: by Ken (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ken Niquette Donna, Sadly, the Rantz family seems to be victims of more adversity than they deserve.

I haven’t finished the book yet, I bought the paperback right before Christmas. What really resonated with me to this point is Joe’s “make your own luck”….”solve your own problem” attitude, pushed on him by his father and stepmother. This is in stark contrast to the group effort required to propel the boat forward.

Also, many complements to Daniel James Brown for his background discussion of the unfolding crisis in Europe. He was quite adept at keeping it in the background as people across the US came to grips with their domestic struggles.

I lost my father in 2016. He spent intermittent time in Seattle with Boeing, and would have greatly enjoyed this book.

Finally, the events of this book leave me wondering…..where will the next high profile event come from that can bring this nation together as it did during those difficult times?

I’m only 33% through the book, but have already recommended it to several friends and family members.


Donna So glad you are enjoying the book. Joe was changed both by his mother’s death at age three and his father and step mother’s abandonment at 14. Then again by his crew experience of having to come together as a team, both physically and emotionally to achieve what seemed impossible. When I knew him I thought of him as the ideal man, not knowing his entire background. He was a good man who made a home and family with Joyce and they stayed in the home in Lake Forest Park in Seattle all their married lives. I hope you will see the movie which does a good job showing the Boys in the Boat and Joe and Joyce’s love. It shows the effort it took for these young men to accomplish a great feat.


Siobhain Donna, what does your family think of the movie. I'm going to see it tomorrow. I wish I had time to reread the book before going, but I know people who have seen the movie without reading the book and loved it.


Donna We loved the movie, leaving with happy tears. It leaves a lot out but got the important parts, the casting was well done, the actors nailed it. I would like to suggest to everyone to listen to the book on Audible. I have listened three times, one just before I saw the movie. Very glad I did!


Donna Just wanted to say that in 2016 I lost my grandson, not my son. Sorry I was not more clear. A parent should not outlive a child and a grandparent surely should not outlive a grandchild.


Siobhain I’m so glad you think so highly of the movie, Donna! Thanks so much for replying!


Donna Ryan wrote: "I am so confused- your son is the grandson of Joe, so that would make you Joe's daughter or step-daughter...right? But then you said you married Joe's son. So..."

I am Joe's daughter in law. I married his son Fred. Our son is Joe's grandson.


message 78: by Jenna (new) - added it

Jenna Jewel How amazing to be related to them. I’m so sorry for the loss of your grandson. Praying for the entire family. Despite being years later, I know the pain never truly fades. We saw the movie two nights ago and I loved it. Had no idea there was a book and so I look forward to reading it ❤️


message 79: by Bob (new) - added it

Bob Rivell I’ve had the book on my list to read since my 4 sons went through high school, mostly to read about young men inspired to overcome their circumstances. I’ve been too busy to read it and didn’t even realize it was made into a movie. Today I found out that the movie did research at Marist in Poughkeepsie, which is where my daughter goes to school. The “Poughkeepsie Refatta” was a big deal back in the day. Can’t wait to read and then see the movie!
My condolences and prayers for you and your family Donna - nobody should bury a child, let alone a grandchild. but great to read more about your family and the connection.


Loretta Hines Thank you so much for writing this review Donna, I’m sorry for your loss. I had never heard of the book till my partner took me to see the movie and I loved it so much I had to read the book because I wanted to know more about the story. Stumbling upon your review though was a surprise, as to your connection to Joe. What a inspiration he was.


message 81: by Mary (new)

Mary Hegnes The house of Eve


Keith Muehler Donna so sorry for your loss.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top