Donna's Reviews > The Boys in the Boat: Nine Americans and Their Epic Quest for Gold at the 1936 Berlin Olympics

The Boys in the Boat by Daniel James Brown
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
10285365
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: biography
Read 2 times. Last read September 5, 2013.

I don't know why I put off reading this book so long, except I was reading other things. BUT when I went to visit my son, who is the grandson of Joe Rantz and named his son Joe after him, I began reading their copy and could not put it down. Everything else I was reading was put aside.

I then realized I would not finish it before I had to leave and besides, I wanted to OWN it. So I got the Kindle version. Besides, my son was also reading it and we had two book marks, his and mine in the book. So it made things easier.

Wow, I was surprised at all the things I learned about Joe and Joyce I had not known before. I remember holding Joe's Olympic gold medal long ago when I first married his son, the first and last such medal I have ever held. I remember because it made such an impression on me. I remember the talk of the other "boys" and how they got together and I remember being invited to the planting of the tree for Joseph Rantz but did not go. I don't remember why. I have always proudly told everyone that my son's grandfather won an Olympic Gold Medal in Hitler's Germany in 1936. Who else can say that? Not many. But really, I had no idea what was involved in that accomplishment.

But after reading this book I realize how very special those boys were, and how important it was that it all came together, the very special men who all had hard upbringings, who had to scrape and scratch for every morsel they ever got, the now legendary boat maker and the coxswain. It took a very unique mix of ingredients to make that win happen and take home that Gold Medal.

But it had to be told in a way that we could all see it,feel it, get it. And Daniel Brown did just that. He interviewed Joe Rantz months before his death.

I remember a man who was tall, handsome, strong and always willing to help. I remember as a young single mother after I had divorced his son, how very warm and welcoming they were to me and how Joe would not only fix my broken down cars but would show me how he did it.

I remember when he fell from the tree when he was still out there too late in his life, climbing trees and cutting them down. I remember saying to myself, if only I could find a man like him, I would keep him. He was my ideal man but I had no idea how he came to be that man.

So now I know.

Update: Sadly last December 15th 2016 At 1:15 pm Joseph Devon Rantz, great grandson of Joe Rantz, was killed in a car accident riding with his friend who was driving in the pouring rain. The car hydroplaned in the rain crossed the median and hit a utility truck and then the bridge abutment. Both boys were wearing seatbelts but the driver was thrown from the car into Dry Creek. Both boys were killed instantly.
We have had tremendous, kind support from the community. We were devastated and just broken by the loss. He was a good kid, 18 years old in his senior year of high school, a lefty pitcher on the varsity baseball team. We loved him and miss him every day.

865 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Boys in the Boat.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 31, 2013 – Started Reading (Kindle Edition)
August 31, 2013 – Shelved (Kindle Edition)
Started Reading
September 5, 2013 – Finished Reading
September 7, 2013 – Shelved as: biography (Kindle Edition)
September 7, 2013 – Shelved
September 7, 2013 – Shelved as: biography
September 7, 2013 – Finished Reading (Kindle Edition)

Comments Showing 1-50 of 82 (82 new)


Dr. Lloyd E. Campbell How nice for you.


Diane wonderful review. Thanks.


Donna Are you related to one of the boys or Joe? "Thanks"?


message 4: by Ryan (new)

Ryan I am so confused- your son is the grandson of Joe, so that would make you Joe's daughter or step-daughter...right? But then you said you married Joe's son. So...


message 5: by Donna (last edited Jan 12, 2024 07:14PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Donna Ryan wrote: "I am so confused- your son is the grandson of Joe, so that would make you Joe's daughter or step-daughter...right? But then you said you married Joe's son. So..."

I was Joe's Daughter-in-law. I was married to Joe's son Fred and our son is Joe's grandson. Our son named his first child Joe after his great grandfather. Sorry if I was unclear.


Vicki I loved your comments and to know he was a good man. There are so many children of the Depression (like Joe, and my parents) who never brought attention to their hardships. My mother was sent out to live with other families when there were too many mouths to feed, and no shoes to go to school. How lucky you were to know him.


message 7: by Donna (last edited Jul 03, 2014 09:55PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Donna Yes I was so glad this book did him justice. It seems that that generation who had little and had to struggle so for everything is a huge contrast from current generation who takes so much for granted.
My older half sister was also sent out to live with others, strangers, and was abandoned at age 16. Like Joe Rantz was at 15.


Nicole Wiebe Just happened to read your comments. Really enjoyed the personal comments. Very cool that your son has this family history.


Donna Thanks, yes it is and now it is his son's and daughter's history too.


Leslie What a gift to have this book as a treasure for your family. So many character traits that we all can learn from. Thanks for sharing your review.


message 11: by Barb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Barb I enjoyed this book so much, in fact could not put it down. How very proud your son and his children must be. Their grandfather was someone to be proud of and now many people know it. You wrote a wonderful review Donna.


Donna Oh thanks. Sorry for the confusion but he was my father in law, my son's grandfather.


Danielle I agree- amazing book for all to read, and what a great history for the Rantz family. I may have met your son while standing on the shore watching the Head of the Lake this fall... I talked to a man while watching the race, who I later learned from someone else nearby that he was Joe Rantz's grandson. Whoever he was, he was very pleasant with my 3 year old daughter and he helped me cheer on my husband in the single. I'm not sure if it was him, it may have been another relative.


Dotty Thanks for your comments about Joe and your relationship through your son. Our neighbor is Jerry Rantz, one of Joe's other sons. I remember when we first moved in to our neighborhood in 1980, Jerry said Joe could build us a split-rail fence like Jerry's. We couldn't afford it, but it would have been nice if we could. Jerry always has had a lot of respect for his dad, how hard he always worked and I can see why. Still need to read this, will as soon as I finish my current book for my book group.


message 15: by Donna (last edited Jun 08, 2016 08:06AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Donna Danielle wrote: "I agree- amazing book for all to read, and what a great history for the Rantz family. I may have met your son while standing on the shore watching the Head of the Lake this fall... I talked to a ma..."

Joe Rantz has other grandsons. My son Devon Rantz (Joe's grandson) and I moved to California over a year ago.


Anita Donna, thank you for your review. I finished the book last night and I really loved it. I loved the story of Joe and his journey as well as learning about rowing and the time period this all happened. What a keep sake treasure for your family!It's always amazing to learn something in depth about someone you already knew and loved, isn't it?


Linda thank you for your comments...I am only a third of the way thru the book...but feel so close to Joe..you are truly blessed to have had him in your life! what an exceptional man.


Donna Thank you for your kind comments, everyone. I think he would be pleasantly surprised to know so many people have enjoyed the story of all the boys. He didn't want to be recognized above any of the others.


Janet Thank you for your comments Donna. It's fantastic that this story has been captured for your family. Daniel James Brown did an outstanding job. Your son will especially appreciate knowing more about his grandfather.


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I delayed reading the book as well. I thought it was more about east cost upper crust rowers for some reason. Boy was I wrong.

I couldn't put it down, Joe's story and the story of the other boys and the history of the sport and boat building and west coast rivalry and east west rivalry was just amazing.

Even knowing the outcome of the final race, how they got there from qualifiers to the finals fr the outside lane in the wind was so gripping.

It was like Sea Biscuit and Unbroken combined. I loved how Joe survived and thrived, truly the greatest generation. So glad your grand children will know the story forever as well!


Donna It is a remarkable story of remarkable men. Totally not about the elite. So glad you enjoyed it.


Terri How lucky your grandson is to have a grand father like Joe. What an admirable man and I have so enjoyed the story of his struggle and victory.


message 23: by DPS (new) - rated it 5 stars

DPS What a wonderful tribute you wrote to Joe. I just started to read the book because my husband said it is terrific. I will carry the picture you drew of him with me as I read the book.


Lynsey Just finished it; I found Joe Rantz's story to be so compelling, and I'm glad that Brown focused on him. So cool that you have a connection to a noteworthy American!


message 25: by Pat (new) - rated it 5 stars

Pat Sweitzer What a great footnote to this story. I suspect we all have some really amazing relatives with stories we din't know. Makes me want to look further back in my genealogy! Each person we see has a a story!


message 26: by Charlene (new)

Charlene Your review has given me the gentle nudge to add the book to my book list! Thanks!


Kathleen Thank you for sharing your connection to Joe. It is an amazing story.


message 28: by Barbara Buch (new)

Barbara Buch I read this several months ago and liked it , however I became a little impatient to finish because it went on too long. Maybe because I was not acquainted with boating. Betty


Rohini Thanks for sharing your story - it brings out a new perspective while I'm reading the book. Makes it more human and less distant ...


Leigh So great that you are part of this family this is a great read. Very special people. I've been to the George Pocock Rowing Center in Seattle where my son-in-law worked for a time. We marveled at all the rowing shells lined up and stacked on the racks. But I had no idea of the history. I'm glad I'm reading it.


message 31: by Jodi (new) - added it

Jodi I can't put the book down. I am almost finished with it. Reading your beautiful words about Joe make me feel so happy he really was the wonderful man he was portrayed as being in the book. Thank you.


Rebecca Rubenstein This summer, my town is reading this book as part of a One Book : One Village concept, so that the community may connect through a shared reading experience. I just finished reading it today and I loved it! Thank you Donna for sharing your connection with Joe, that is so special!


message 33: by Sue (last edited Jul 20, 2016 04:15PM) (new)

Sue Spaulding I just finished this powerful book. Joe Rantz was amazing, and this is a strong story of courage, perseverance and forgiveness. It troubled me, though, that Joe's father was never confronted with the devastation and hurt his actions brought to his son. Since you are part of his extended family, maybe you can solve the mystery as to why Harry Sr. is never confronted, and whyHharry and Thula never stepped up and acknowledged their unspeakably cruel actions. Did Harry Sr. ever apologize?


Jlfigueroa Extraordinary man an inspiration to many.


Donna Sue wrote: "I just finished this powerful book. Joe Rantz was amazing, and this is a strong story of courage, perseverance and forgiveness. It troubled me, though, that Joe's father was never confronted with t..."

I honestly don't know. Joe never talked about it. I can ask Judy, his daughter, who travels around giving speeches and answering questions, all over the world.


Donna Sue, I asked Judy, Joe's dad about your question. She says there was no formal apology but Joe did welcome him into his home later and they played music together. Joe played the banjo.


message 37: by Maha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Maha Hall heartwarming


Barbara Nutting Please read the review I just posted- that was one powerful story!


Ruthmgon wonderful review and thread. How special to know this story from that angle.


Sandra Croteau Donna, I’m so sorry for your loss


Siobhain So sorry for your loss.


Rachel Lee So sorry for your loss. That is heartbreaking news to read.


Donna I really appreciate all the kind comments here about losing our beloved Joe who was named after his great grandfather Joe Rantz. He is always with us in our hearts.


Cat Gray Very sorry to hear of your loss. May his memory be a blessing.


Donna Thank you Cat.


message 46: by Ira (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ira Livingston Sorry for your loss, but thank you for the very personal review


Kayrene I just wanted to sit and cry for Joe Rance, for how he was treated by his own father! They were all such underdogs. I LOVED this book...not enough stars to convey it. I am SO sorry for your loss. God bless you.


Laura Freeland Not only was the book wonderful to read, I found your review so touching to personalize your father- in- law as you did. I am so sorry for your loss. I find beauty in the fact that so many strangers like myself have read your review of this amazing man and can only imagine his humility, joy and determination must have also been in your son. May you always be comforted by the beautiful memories of both these men.


Jayne This was probably my favorite book this year. I, too, put it off for no good reason and stopped everything while I read it. Your personal review was heart warming. I’m so sorry the loss of your grandson. My prayers will be with you for comfort and peace.


Pamela Mathis-Yon My heart is with you , a tragic loss . So very hard to understand. I hope that you find comfort some way . 💔❤️💔❤️


« previous 1
back to top