What do you think?
Rate this book
Counterfeit Lady #1
City of Lies
From the national bestselling author of the Gaslight Mysteries comes the first Counterfeit Lady novel—the intriguing start of a historical mystery series featuring woman-on-the-run Elizabeth Miles.
Every woman plays a part—but some are more dangerous than others...
Like most women, Elizabeth Miles assumes many roles; unlike most, hers have made her a woman on the run. Living on the edge of society, Elizabeth uses her guile to relieve so-called respectable men of their ill-gotten gains. But brutal and greedy entrepreneur Oscar Thornton is out for blood. He’s lost a great deal of money and is not going to forgive a woman for outwitting him.
With his thugs hot on her trail, Elizabeth seizes the moment to blend in with a group of women who have an agenda of their own. She never expects to like or understand these privileged women, but she soon comes to respect their intentions, forming an unlikely bond with the wealthy matriarch of the group whose son, Gideon, is the rarest of species—an honest man in a dishonest world.
Elizabeth knows she’s playing a risky game, and her deception could be revealed at any moment, possibly even by sharp-eyed Gideon. Nor has she been forgotten by Thornton, who’s biding his time, waiting to strike. Elizabeth must draw on her wits and every last ounce of courage she possesses to keep her new life from being cut short by this vicious shadow from her past.
312 pages, Hardcover
First published November 7, 2017
644 people are currently reading
4,926 people want to read
About the author
Victoria Thompson
75 books2,411 followersVictoria Thompson was a beloved authoress of 'standard mystery' novels.
This middle of the road tone is not violent like a 'thriller' but unsanitized (NOT light like a 'cozy mystery'), is unflinchingly adult, serious, and dark.
Humour, romance, family, and compassion balance out the crime part of dear Victoria's unforgettable mysteries.
This middle of the road tone is not violent like a 'thriller' but unsanitized (NOT light like a 'cozy mystery'), is unflinchingly adult, serious, and dark.
Humour, romance, family, and compassion balance out the crime part of dear Victoria's unforgettable mysteries.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 590 reviews
July 21, 2021
I enjoy this author's Gaslight Mysteries series so much I obviously had to try this series as well.
At first it did not grab me. I am not a fan of grifters as I always find their supposed clever schemes simplistic and wonder why their marks do not see straight through them. Maybe if you are really greedy you believe anything,which was apparently what happened in this book.
There was a lot of historic detail about the Suffragist Movement which was interesting but I was losing interest in the book as the time in prison went on and on. Then suddenly the totally charismatic Gideon Bates arrived on the scene and the whole picture changed. Actually I think the story picked up pace at that time too, but the result was the same, and I read the last third of the book totally engrossed and at top speed.
It will be interesting to see how the author handles the two main characters with their opposing principles in future books. I am looking forward to finding out.
At first it did not grab me. I am not a fan of grifters as I always find their supposed clever schemes simplistic and wonder why their marks do not see straight through them. Maybe if you are really greedy you believe anything,which was apparently what happened in this book.
There was a lot of historic detail about the Suffragist Movement which was interesting but I was losing interest in the book as the time in prison went on and on. Then suddenly the totally charismatic Gideon Bates arrived on the scene and the whole picture changed. Actually I think the story picked up pace at that time too, but the result was the same, and I read the last third of the book totally engrossed and at top speed.
It will be interesting to see how the author handles the two main characters with their opposing principles in future books. I am looking forward to finding out.
November 5, 2018
I recently discovered this author (Thank you Melisa) and started this new series "Counterfeit Lady". I read Book 2 first and absolutely loved it and then found this one on Audible. We get introduced to Elizabeth Miles, a grifter who gets caught up in a con deal gone bad with the wrong man. She has to use her skills to stay alive and out of danger.
I really enjoyed the time period and getting all the backstory on the main characters that I met in book two. It is so well written and has appealing characters. I enjoyed the whole adventure they took me on and even a bit of a romance is hinted at. I do think the second book is even better.
Now, I'll be eagerly awaiting Book 3 in this series. If you enjoy an engaging historical mystery, this one was a rollicking adventure.
I really enjoyed the time period and getting all the backstory on the main characters that I met in book two. It is so well written and has appealing characters. I enjoyed the whole adventure they took me on and even a bit of a romance is hinted at. I do think the second book is even better.
Now, I'll be eagerly awaiting Book 3 in this series. If you enjoy an engaging historical mystery, this one was a rollicking adventure.
December 6, 2018
I have wanted to read the books in this series for awhile, since so many of my book friends have had nice things to say about them and so before 2018 goes out, at least I did get to this one.
Put together a few grifters, a few marks, a very angry vindictive mob type boss, and a few suffragettes and you have the makings of this book. Elizabeth Miles, bless her felonious heart, is a con lady. Together with her brother, and her father they plot ways in which to help themselves to a "bit" of money. All seems to be going well until they tick off the vile Oscar Thorton for he is not a man to let anyone pull anything on him.
In an attempt to escape the nasty Thorton, Elizabeth hooks up with a group of suffragettes, winds up in jail with them, and ultimately meets a man who she will come to love. Elizabeth is beautiful, (of course), super smart (is there any question of that? ) and has a plan, a way to escape the evil Thorton and his henchmen while saving the day and getting the man of her dreams. It's all in good fun or is it? As Elizabeth plays a game of wits, the families of the suffragettes come to love her as they consider her bold and daring. They even forgive the past transgressions of her life. Will Elizabeth succeed in all, or will she wind up one of Thorton's bad mistakes?
This was a fun book, which let us into a bit of the workings of the suffragettes and introduced the heroine, Elizabeth, into a series she would populate. Not sure if this reader will pursue more adventures with Elizabeth, but I did somewhat like this book so perhaps in the future the next series book will call my name.
Thanks to my local library for this one.
My reviews can also be seen here: https://yayareadslotsofbooks.wordpres...
Put together a few grifters, a few marks, a very angry vindictive mob type boss, and a few suffragettes and you have the makings of this book. Elizabeth Miles, bless her felonious heart, is a con lady. Together with her brother, and her father they plot ways in which to help themselves to a "bit" of money. All seems to be going well until they tick off the vile Oscar Thorton for he is not a man to let anyone pull anything on him.
In an attempt to escape the nasty Thorton, Elizabeth hooks up with a group of suffragettes, winds up in jail with them, and ultimately meets a man who she will come to love. Elizabeth is beautiful, (of course), super smart (is there any question of that? ) and has a plan, a way to escape the evil Thorton and his henchmen while saving the day and getting the man of her dreams. It's all in good fun or is it? As Elizabeth plays a game of wits, the families of the suffragettes come to love her as they consider her bold and daring. They even forgive the past transgressions of her life. Will Elizabeth succeed in all, or will she wind up one of Thorton's bad mistakes?
This was a fun book, which let us into a bit of the workings of the suffragettes and introduced the heroine, Elizabeth, into a series she would populate. Not sure if this reader will pursue more adventures with Elizabeth, but I did somewhat like this book so perhaps in the future the next series book will call my name.
Thanks to my local library for this one.
My reviews can also be seen here: https://yayareadslotsofbooks.wordpres...
January 2, 2019
3.25 ⭐
Starting the new year with American suffragettes, grifters and a somewhat convincing con, mean villains, beta heroes and almost feminist female characters.
'twas a fun read. (Except for the initial 30% of the book)
Starting the new year with American suffragettes, grifters and a somewhat convincing con, mean villains, beta heroes and almost feminist female characters.
'twas a fun read. (Except for the initial 30% of the book)
July 28, 2021
This review can also be found at https://carolesrandomlife.com/
I thought that this was very good! I have had this book in my queue for years but never seemed to be able to work it into my reading schedule. When I noticed that my local library had a copy of the audiobook available to borrow, I decided that it was finally time to see what this book was about. I found it be quite entertaining so I am glad that I finally gave it a chance.
Elizabeth isn’t like most women in her time since she works with a team of grifters. To escape capture, she joins a group of women fighting for the right to vote and ends up going to jail with them. I loved the group of women that she was with while in jail. She became a vital member of the group and I really enjoyed the way that they supported and encouraged each other. When they are released, she goes home with one of the women she became close to in jail and has the opportunity to get to know Gideon a lot better.
I thought that this book was rather exciting at times. It was really amazing that this book is only set 100 years ago since this world looked so different from the one we live in today. I liked the chemistry between Elizabeth and Gideon and thought that they worked well together despite having very different views. I enjoyed the fact that the suffrage movement played such a vital role in the story and I liked that LGBTQ issues were also addressed.
Kate Forbes did a very nice job with the narration. I liked the various voices she used for the character dialogue. I felt like she was able to add a lot of emotion and excitement to the story and her pacing was well done. I believe that her performance added to my overall enjoyment of the story.
I would recommend this book to others. Elizabeth was a great character and I loved the fact that she often operates in a morally grey area. I do plan to read more of this series soon.
I received a digital review copy of this book from Berkley Publishing Group via Edelweiss and borrowed a copy of the audiobook from my local library.
I thought that this was very good! I have had this book in my queue for years but never seemed to be able to work it into my reading schedule. When I noticed that my local library had a copy of the audiobook available to borrow, I decided that it was finally time to see what this book was about. I found it be quite entertaining so I am glad that I finally gave it a chance.
Elizabeth isn’t like most women in her time since she works with a team of grifters. To escape capture, she joins a group of women fighting for the right to vote and ends up going to jail with them. I loved the group of women that she was with while in jail. She became a vital member of the group and I really enjoyed the way that they supported and encouraged each other. When they are released, she goes home with one of the women she became close to in jail and has the opportunity to get to know Gideon a lot better.
I thought that this book was rather exciting at times. It was really amazing that this book is only set 100 years ago since this world looked so different from the one we live in today. I liked the chemistry between Elizabeth and Gideon and thought that they worked well together despite having very different views. I enjoyed the fact that the suffrage movement played such a vital role in the story and I liked that LGBTQ issues were also addressed.
Kate Forbes did a very nice job with the narration. I liked the various voices she used for the character dialogue. I felt like she was able to add a lot of emotion and excitement to the story and her pacing was well done. I believe that her performance added to my overall enjoyment of the story.
I would recommend this book to others. Elizabeth was a great character and I loved the fact that she often operates in a morally grey area. I do plan to read more of this series soon.
I received a digital review copy of this book from Berkley Publishing Group via Edelweiss and borrowed a copy of the audiobook from my local library.
January 6, 2018
Rich with fascinating historical detail, Thompson’s new series dives into the worlds of suffragists and con-men. City of Lies combines a cunning protagonist with a simmering romance and gripping suspense to form a story that is certain to beguile readers hook, line and sinker.
October 5, 2017
It was supposed to be a great con, easy money, but this time Elizabeth Miles finds the “respectable” businessman she has conned is a brutal and deadly con man himself and he is out for both his lost money and revenge. Running scared, Elizabeth gets herself carted off with the women of the Suffragists’ movement and for a woman on the run, jail may be the safest place for her.
Little did Elizabeth realize, these women would change her life and introduce her to a world of privilege and women who are equally as strong as she is and not the pampered princesses she always thought them to be. Now she has one last con to pull and it will take all of her skills, skills that could cost her newfound friendships and even her heart. Who knew doing the right thing could be even riskier than being a grifter?
With a villain as dastardly as Snidely Whiplash and a romantic interest as honorable as Dudley Dooright, our sweet Elizabeth is up to her neck in lies, cons and a new found conscience that lights up each page of this fast-paced and fascinating read!
CITY OF LIES by Victoria Thompson provides a little history, a little drama, some tense moments, and a delightful cast of characters that make this trip back in time a wonderful escape! While Elizabeth may not be the typical heroine, she is a truly memorable and lovable character who steals the show as she manages to shine across each page and wiggle herself out of each predicament she finds herself in! A fun read for sure!
I received an ARC edition from Berkley in exchange for my honest and voluntary review!
Series: Counterfeit Lady - Book 1
Publisher: Berkley (November 7, 2017)
Publication Date: November 7, 2017
Genre: Historical Mystery/Suspense
Print Length: 320 pages
Available from: Amazon | Barnes & Noble
For Reviews & More: http://tometender.blogspot.com
Little did Elizabeth realize, these women would change her life and introduce her to a world of privilege and women who are equally as strong as she is and not the pampered princesses she always thought them to be. Now she has one last con to pull and it will take all of her skills, skills that could cost her newfound friendships and even her heart. Who knew doing the right thing could be even riskier than being a grifter?
With a villain as dastardly as Snidely Whiplash and a romantic interest as honorable as Dudley Dooright, our sweet Elizabeth is up to her neck in lies, cons and a new found conscience that lights up each page of this fast-paced and fascinating read!
CITY OF LIES by Victoria Thompson provides a little history, a little drama, some tense moments, and a delightful cast of characters that make this trip back in time a wonderful escape! While Elizabeth may not be the typical heroine, she is a truly memorable and lovable character who steals the show as she manages to shine across each page and wiggle herself out of each predicament she finds herself in! A fun read for sure!
I received an ARC edition from Berkley in exchange for my honest and voluntary review!
Series: Counterfeit Lady - Book 1
Publisher: Berkley (November 7, 2017)
Publication Date: November 7, 2017
Genre: Historical Mystery/Suspense
Print Length: 320 pages
Available from: Amazon | Barnes & Noble
For Reviews & More: http://tometender.blogspot.com
October 31, 2017
3.75 stars Thank you to First-to-Read and Berkley for allowing me the chance to read this ARC. This book publishes on 11/7/17.
Elizabeth Miles is a grifter. She lies, steals and cheats for a living. It is in the process of a job that she becomes involved with a Women's Rights Movement where she falls into a suffragette march as she flees from danger. She is soon jailed, along with the women in this march, and sent to a workhouse where she feels she will be temporarily safe from the people she was fleeing. Lo and behold, who manages to free them from this workhouse but the very person Elizabeth was hoping to remain hidden from.
Now Elizabeth has to put her resourcefulness to use. She must become the demure, gentile suffragette that these women believe her to be. Then she finds she is besieged by two separate suitors and must lie to each of them to protect both herself and her new found friends. But what effect is this having on Elizabeth? Can she change? Will she always be a grifter or will one of her suitors finally win her heart?
Victoria Thompson is also the author of the Gaslight Mysteries. She is very good at Victorian era novels and series. This is the first Book of the Counterfeit Lady series. In her books you find an immediate sense of belonging and fitting right into the world she has created. You emphasize with the highs and lows of the protagonist. Time, space and distance fall away as you read and savor that which you find is just out of reach, as you take in the familiar underpinning of a world in the early 1900's.
Elizabeth Miles is a grifter. She lies, steals and cheats for a living. It is in the process of a job that she becomes involved with a Women's Rights Movement where she falls into a suffragette march as she flees from danger. She is soon jailed, along with the women in this march, and sent to a workhouse where she feels she will be temporarily safe from the people she was fleeing. Lo and behold, who manages to free them from this workhouse but the very person Elizabeth was hoping to remain hidden from.
Now Elizabeth has to put her resourcefulness to use. She must become the demure, gentile suffragette that these women believe her to be. Then she finds she is besieged by two separate suitors and must lie to each of them to protect both herself and her new found friends. But what effect is this having on Elizabeth? Can she change? Will she always be a grifter or will one of her suitors finally win her heart?
Victoria Thompson is also the author of the Gaslight Mysteries. She is very good at Victorian era novels and series. This is the first Book of the Counterfeit Lady series. In her books you find an immediate sense of belonging and fitting right into the world she has created. You emphasize with the highs and lows of the protagonist. Time, space and distance fall away as you read and savor that which you find is just out of reach, as you take in the familiar underpinning of a world in the early 1900's.
November 28, 2017
The story takes us to 1917 Washington, D.C. and New York City. Women are protesting for their right to vote, but none of that matters to Elizabeth Miles. She has other interests in mind.
Elizabeth Miles is a con artist. Along with her brother, Jake, she schemes to steal money from less-than-nice men like Oscar Thornton. Unfortunately, during one of their schemes, their plans take a turn for the worst. Once Thornton finds out, it’s over for the brother and sister team. They get separated. Elizabeth has no idea what happened to her brother, but she has no choice but to go on the run.
Elizabeth manages to blend in with a group of suffragists and joins their protest under an assumed name. She is not at all upset when they are arrested and jailed. Prison is the perfect place to hide from Thornton. However, life in prison isn't very enjoyable.
Much to Elizabeth’s surprise, she finds herself forming a tight bond with some of these wealthy women, including Mrs. Bates and Anna. Thanks to Mrs. Bates attorney son, Gideon, the women are freed from jail, but Thornton is still hot on her heels. She must find a place to hide. Fortunately for her, Anna insists she stay with her family. Anna agrees, but is she really safe there?
The author weaves actual historical facts into this fictional story. I found the storyline and characters fascinating. The author did a great job of making the main character likeable and sympathetic, despite her being a con artist and thief.
I’m not really much of an historical fiction fan, but the premise and setting grabbed my interest. I must admit, I originally thought this was a murder mystery, but it’s not. It’s more like fiction with romance and some suspense mixed together.
It’s a gripping, cleverly written story that had my attention from the start. I was immediately transported back in time. I felt I was standing right alongside Elizabeth.
I enjoyed every minute of this one. I’m so glad I stepped out of my normal genre to try it. This is the first of a new series and I’m looking forward to reading the next one.
FTC Disclosure: I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Elizabeth Miles is a con artist. Along with her brother, Jake, she schemes to steal money from less-than-nice men like Oscar Thornton. Unfortunately, during one of their schemes, their plans take a turn for the worst. Once Thornton finds out, it’s over for the brother and sister team. They get separated. Elizabeth has no idea what happened to her brother, but she has no choice but to go on the run.
Elizabeth manages to blend in with a group of suffragists and joins their protest under an assumed name. She is not at all upset when they are arrested and jailed. Prison is the perfect place to hide from Thornton. However, life in prison isn't very enjoyable.
Much to Elizabeth’s surprise, she finds herself forming a tight bond with some of these wealthy women, including Mrs. Bates and Anna. Thanks to Mrs. Bates attorney son, Gideon, the women are freed from jail, but Thornton is still hot on her heels. She must find a place to hide. Fortunately for her, Anna insists she stay with her family. Anna agrees, but is she really safe there?
The author weaves actual historical facts into this fictional story. I found the storyline and characters fascinating. The author did a great job of making the main character likeable and sympathetic, despite her being a con artist and thief.
I’m not really much of an historical fiction fan, but the premise and setting grabbed my interest. I must admit, I originally thought this was a murder mystery, but it’s not. It’s more like fiction with romance and some suspense mixed together.
It’s a gripping, cleverly written story that had my attention from the start. I was immediately transported back in time. I felt I was standing right alongside Elizabeth.
I enjoyed every minute of this one. I’m so glad I stepped out of my normal genre to try it. This is the first of a new series and I’m looking forward to reading the next one.
FTC Disclosure: I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
November 19, 2017
2.5 stars
After reading all of Ms. Thompson’s Gaslight mysteries and becoming slightly disenchanted with the last few stories, I was excited to find City of Lies. IMHO, it was not a mystery. I thought of it as historical fiction with a few elements taken from true events. The upside for me was researching this time-gone-by. What was the truth, only you can decide.
Though no year was given, it appeared to take place in late August, 1917 and the weeks that followed. This was when the women suffragettes actually picketed President Woodrow Wilson in front of the White House. It was the underlying theme that encompassed City of Lies.
If you are familiar with Maeve from the Gaslight books, grifter Elizabeth Miles was taken from the same mold: stilted, blunt, even harsh at times. If I continue to read this series, Ineed hope her character blooms.
Like many first stories, there were quite a few characters and subplots. There was an interesting blend of WWI, Wilson’s messy handling of the Suffragettes and an oily secondary strand of selling arms to the American government. And, of course, the con. Plus a confused LBGT character and two men fascinated with one woman. Instead of polishing it off in less than 48 hours, it took me days to complete it. In this case I thought it would help if ‘less is more’.
It saddens me to give City of Lies 2 1/2 stars. There was an abrupt HEA that could have made it a stand-alone; I assume there will be other stories. If I read the next one, it will be to see if the MCs expand.
After reading all of Ms. Thompson’s Gaslight mysteries and becoming slightly disenchanted with the last few stories, I was excited to find City of Lies. IMHO, it was not a mystery. I thought of it as historical fiction with a few elements taken from true events. The upside for me was researching this time-gone-by. What was the truth, only you can decide.
Though no year was given, it appeared to take place in late August, 1917 and the weeks that followed. This was when the women suffragettes actually picketed President Woodrow Wilson in front of the White House. It was the underlying theme that encompassed City of Lies.
If you are familiar with Maeve from the Gaslight books, grifter Elizabeth Miles was taken from the same mold: stilted, blunt, even harsh at times. If I continue to read this series, I
Like many first stories, there were quite a few characters and subplots. There was an interesting blend of WWI, Wilson’s messy handling of the Suffragettes and an oily secondary strand of selling arms to the American government. And, of course, the con. Plus a confused LBGT character and two men fascinated with one woman. Instead of polishing it off in less than 48 hours, it took me days to complete it. In this case I thought it would help if ‘less is more’.
It saddens me to give City of Lies 2 1/2 stars. There was an abrupt HEA that could have made it a stand-alone; I assume there will be other stories. If I read the next one, it will be to see if the MCs expand.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 9, 2017
Elizabeth Miles makes her living as a con woman, an unusual profession for a woman in 1917. However, when her latest con goes south, she finds herself on the run from the mark’s goons. In her attempts to escape, she joins a group of suffragists outside the White House and is delighted when they are arrested. But has she truly escaped the men searching for her?
If you pick up this book expecting a murder and five suspects, you’ll be disappointed. However, with those adjusted expectations pick up this book because it is wonderful. The story is captivating and moves quickly; I always had a hard time putting the book down. This may be the first in a series, but the characters are already strong. I’m not normally one to root for a criminal, but I couldn’t help but root for Elizabeth in this book. Real history is woven in without slowing down the fictional story at all. I’m not sure where the series will go from this wonderful beginning, but I can’t wait to find out.
NOTE: I received a copy of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
If you pick up this book expecting a murder and five suspects, you’ll be disappointed. However, with those adjusted expectations pick up this book because it is wonderful. The story is captivating and moves quickly; I always had a hard time putting the book down. This may be the first in a series, but the characters are already strong. I’m not normally one to root for a criminal, but I couldn’t help but root for Elizabeth in this book. Real history is woven in without slowing down the fictional story at all. I’m not sure where the series will go from this wonderful beginning, but I can’t wait to find out.
NOTE: I received a copy of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
November 29, 2017
Set in a time where the world was on the cusp of change, Thompson's City of Lies will pull you in with both intrigue for the mystery behind Elizabeth's life and the fascinating con that this woman and her brother are pulling on others.
With hints of danger and a touch of romance, this was a fun read that kept me entertained and interested right up to the very end.
With hints of danger and a touch of romance, this was a fun read that kept me entertained and interested right up to the very end.
December 7, 2021
I wanted to start with the first book of the series, and this was it published 2017. My thoughts on the book are that it's a lot of fun but you have to suspend all disbelief. It has Con artists, instalove, LGBT, a villain, an honest man and suffragettes. There were many characters to lay out and I thought the plot was divided into the workhouse and then the romance con. I am on the fence about a 3 or a 4 but I just enjoyed the book, and it has some witty dialogue so looking forward to book 2.
February 23, 2021
In terms of (no) originality and a familiar con set up, this story should probably be a 3 star read, but I enjoyed it more! Charming hf lite.
February 9, 2021
3.5 stars
I loved the early 20th century setting of this book and the role of suffragists within it. That element to the story line and its beginning chapters were my favorite. The romance and mystery were secondary for me. While I enjoyed the characters and the main protagonists, I did struggle with the heroine and her nefarious deeds. It was a unique choice for a heroine, but by the end of the book I hadn’t felt like she was redeemed and the hero had too easily overlooked and accepted her unethical activities. I’m willing to continue the series to see if and how the author shapes the heroine through subsequent books.
November 6, 2017
City of Lies set in the 1920s both in Washington and New York home to the Four Hundred, Thompson shares an engaging tale about a woman who's running a grift with her brother. When things go terribly wrong she is forced to hide among a group of rallying female suffragists. The tale that unfolds was clever and engaging. So much so that I finished the tale in just two sitting.
Thompson weaves historical facts, friendship, LGBT issues, women's rights and a dash of romance into this suspenseful tale. In the author's notes, Thompson describes how some of the events our heroine Elizabeth Miles, Anna and others suffered through, actually happened during the Women's Movement of the 1920s. Of course, she took some liberties, but I love when actual events are woven into a tale. It gave an air of authenticity and notched up the suspense aspects.
Elizabeth is such a lively character, and I found myself holding my breath with the situations she found herself in. Her cleverness and ability to change the outcome of her circumstances kept me flipping the pages. Thompson made Elizabeth's story of escaping near death to befriending Anna seem genuine. I liked Anna, her brother, and mother and a large part of the scenes are spent in their home. Anna wants her life to matter, doesn't fancy marriage and finds herself drawn to Elizabeth. I loved the added threads concerning her and appreciated how the author addressed them particularly the LGBT issue. In the 1920s loving, someone of the same sex was never discussed despite the fact that homosexuality existed. The frank conversation and support were refreshing.
We are treated to a romance, well several actually. I loved seeing Elizabeth tackle these moments, use them to her advantage and become flounder entirely by others. The tale was balanced with the suspense thread at the center, and romantic elements threaded through the story. These features allowed for character growth, suspense and delightful moments to make your heart pitter-patter. Will Elizabeth escape or end up at the mercy of the villain? Who will get their heart-broken? It was all so engaging. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
Thompson weaves historical facts, friendship, LGBT issues, women's rights and a dash of romance into this suspenseful tale. In the author's notes, Thompson describes how some of the events our heroine Elizabeth Miles, Anna and others suffered through, actually happened during the Women's Movement of the 1920s. Of course, she took some liberties, but I love when actual events are woven into a tale. It gave an air of authenticity and notched up the suspense aspects.
Elizabeth is such a lively character, and I found myself holding my breath with the situations she found herself in. Her cleverness and ability to change the outcome of her circumstances kept me flipping the pages. Thompson made Elizabeth's story of escaping near death to befriending Anna seem genuine. I liked Anna, her brother, and mother and a large part of the scenes are spent in their home. Anna wants her life to matter, doesn't fancy marriage and finds herself drawn to Elizabeth. I loved the added threads concerning her and appreciated how the author addressed them particularly the LGBT issue. In the 1920s loving, someone of the same sex was never discussed despite the fact that homosexuality existed. The frank conversation and support were refreshing.
We are treated to a romance, well several actually. I loved seeing Elizabeth tackle these moments, use them to her advantage and become flounder entirely by others. The tale was balanced with the suspense thread at the center, and romantic elements threaded through the story. These features allowed for character growth, suspense and delightful moments to make your heart pitter-patter. Will Elizabeth escape or end up at the mercy of the villain? Who will get their heart-broken? It was all so engaging. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
October 29, 2017
4 "The Grifter Suffragist" Stars!
Lovers of historical fiction that takes place during the women's suffragist movement in the US of the early 1900s (circa 1920s) will not want to miss City of Lies. There is also a dash of mystery and suspense thrown in to keep the reader guessing. Additionally, while this is not a traditional historical romance title, I also believe that there is enough of a romance thread (even the beginnings of a romance triangle) to make this historical fiction/mystery title also of interest to those who enjoy a historical romance titles.
When a con goes bad, grifter Elizabeth (Lizzie) Miles finds herself on the run. Believing their mark (Oscar Thornton) has likely done in her brother, she's left with no choice but to seek desperate measures. It's at that moment--as she's running through the streets of 1920s Washington DC--that she lands eyes on her possible salvation, a women's suffragist march (mostly high society ladies who were protesting to earn the right to vote). She quickly throws herself into the parade of women hoping to blend in, and when the entire group is arrested, Lizzie couldn't be happier as she knows it will give her a safe haven from Thornton and his crew that is out looking for her.
What Lizzie, however, never could of imagined is that she would soon come to understand what this group of high society women (a class she many times pretended to be in her cons, but never before felt a kinship with) was fighting for. What at first is just sheer determination to fit in, soon becomes a leadership style and showing of courage that bring her to the attention of Mrs. Bates, one of the leaders of the movement, and Anna Vanderslice, a young suffragist who quickly becomes her devoted friend.
The women endure terrible treatment in jail as its clear that politically the administration is trying to make an example of them in order to discourage them and others from demonstrating again. This, however, doesn't deter them in their beliefs. Fortunately, Anna's brother (David) and Mrs. Bates son (Gideon, who is a lawyer) help secure a writ of habeas corpus, though there attempts to find the deputy to serve it on are less fruitful (at least initially). Eventually, however, the women are released which of course is great news for all the prisoners, except Lizzie who now must try to evade Thornton again. Fortunately, Lizzie also makes an impression on David and Gideon, who each want to woe her in their own way.
Will Lizzie be able to maintain the friendships she has made and stay safe from Thornton? Moreover, Lizzie is no high society lady, even if she chooses to stay with her new friends, how will she maintain the illusion she has crafted? Will they find out who she really is? And if so will they remain by her side?
City of Lies was a fast-action historical fiction title that kept me interested both with the suspense and the interesting and varied inter-relationships among the many characters. I look forward to reading more of Victoria Thompson's titles in the future.
Source: Review copy provided for review purposes.
Lovers of historical fiction that takes place during the women's suffragist movement in the US of the early 1900s (circa 1920s) will not want to miss City of Lies. There is also a dash of mystery and suspense thrown in to keep the reader guessing. Additionally, while this is not a traditional historical romance title, I also believe that there is enough of a romance thread (even the beginnings of a romance triangle) to make this historical fiction/mystery title also of interest to those who enjoy a historical romance titles.
When a con goes bad, grifter Elizabeth (Lizzie) Miles finds herself on the run. Believing their mark (Oscar Thornton) has likely done in her brother, she's left with no choice but to seek desperate measures. It's at that moment--as she's running through the streets of 1920s Washington DC--that she lands eyes on her possible salvation, a women's suffragist march (mostly high society ladies who were protesting to earn the right to vote). She quickly throws herself into the parade of women hoping to blend in, and when the entire group is arrested, Lizzie couldn't be happier as she knows it will give her a safe haven from Thornton and his crew that is out looking for her.
What Lizzie, however, never could of imagined is that she would soon come to understand what this group of high society women (a class she many times pretended to be in her cons, but never before felt a kinship with) was fighting for. What at first is just sheer determination to fit in, soon becomes a leadership style and showing of courage that bring her to the attention of Mrs. Bates, one of the leaders of the movement, and Anna Vanderslice, a young suffragist who quickly becomes her devoted friend.
The women endure terrible treatment in jail as its clear that politically the administration is trying to make an example of them in order to discourage them and others from demonstrating again. This, however, doesn't deter them in their beliefs. Fortunately, Anna's brother (David) and Mrs. Bates son (Gideon, who is a lawyer) help secure a writ of habeas corpus, though there attempts to find the deputy to serve it on are less fruitful (at least initially). Eventually, however, the women are released which of course is great news for all the prisoners, except Lizzie who now must try to evade Thornton again. Fortunately, Lizzie also makes an impression on David and Gideon, who each want to woe her in their own way.
Will Lizzie be able to maintain the friendships she has made and stay safe from Thornton? Moreover, Lizzie is no high society lady, even if she chooses to stay with her new friends, how will she maintain the illusion she has crafted? Will they find out who she really is? And if so will they remain by her side?
City of Lies was a fast-action historical fiction title that kept me interested both with the suspense and the interesting and varied inter-relationships among the many characters. I look forward to reading more of Victoria Thompson's titles in the future.
Source: Review copy provided for review purposes.
August 19, 2021
I absolutely loved this book. Any book that includes con artists, and especially smart female ones always intrigues me. When combined with the history of the suffrage movement, I felt like this book was made for me. The use of the the rich history of the suffrage movement was fresh and new, and it was clear that Victoria Thompson put quite a bit of research into it. While the book had me hooked from the beginning, there was a part towards the middle where I wasn't sure I liked where the story was heading. However, Thompson turned it around and the ending was amazing. This is a great pick for anyone looking for a historical fiction drama, or for anyone who likes stories about sly and smart women. While I did love the character of Elizabeth, sometimes I got frustrated with the way that she was portrayed. I kept having to remind myself that this book was set in the early 20th century, and that whether she was a con artist or not, she would act more demure than women today. The character was well written though, and I look forward to seeing how her character will develop in future books. I do believe that this is misclassified as a detective mystery, because while there is a slight mystery in how the con is going to be pulled off, there is no crime that is trying to be solved. I think this book is better classified as a suspense drama, or a historical fiction.
NOTE: I received a free advanced readers copy of this book due to my job as a bookseller. I have not been paid for my opinions, and all of my opinions are my own.
NOTE: I received a free advanced readers copy of this book due to my job as a bookseller. I have not been paid for my opinions, and all of my opinions are my own.
November 7, 2018
*Source* Publisher
*Genre* Historical Fiction
*Rating* 3.5-4
*Thoughts*
City of Lies is the first installment in author Victoria Thompson's Counterfeit Lady historical mystery series. The story features Elizabeth Miles, a young con woman who finds herself embroiled in intrigue in turn of the century New York. For the sake of this book, the year is 1917. America is about to enter World War I, but there is something on the home front that has driven some powerful men absolutely crazy. The Suffragist Movement is putting pressure on then President Wilson to pass legislation that will give women the right to vote.
*Full Review @ Gizmos Reviews*
https://gizmosreviews.blogspot.com/20...
*Genre* Historical Fiction
*Rating* 3.5-4
*Thoughts*
City of Lies is the first installment in author Victoria Thompson's Counterfeit Lady historical mystery series. The story features Elizabeth Miles, a young con woman who finds herself embroiled in intrigue in turn of the century New York. For the sake of this book, the year is 1917. America is about to enter World War I, but there is something on the home front that has driven some powerful men absolutely crazy. The Suffragist Movement is putting pressure on then President Wilson to pass legislation that will give women the right to vote.
*Full Review @ Gizmos Reviews*
https://gizmosreviews.blogspot.com/20...
September 28, 2021
This was like three different books crammed together - We had the grifter/con scam parts 1 & 2. Then we had the suffragette/prison story. Then we had the romance.
Unfortunately none of the stories separately were very well done except the suffragette/prison story thread - but then that was dropped like a hot potato and hardly ever referenced again once the women were out of prison. Weird to make it so central and the best dramatic part of this book and then just let it slip away.
The con/scam thread was a little confusing, Lizzie's role is rather minor in part 1 of it - and her cries of "i knew it would go wrong but he wouldn't listen to me" were hopelessly ineffectual. Other than batting her eyes and running away she contributed nothing much of anything. In part 2 of the scam, yes it was her idea. But now I know her back story and have met her criminal family and no way do I believe in Lizzie now - how hopelessly naive she is, that she's virtuous (???) which just didn't fit - but no, she comes from a 'noble' kind of criminal element - Yeah, right.
And then there was the romance - it was insta-love on his part, and attraction on hers. He sees those piercing blue eyes and straight spine and that's it - he's in love. She likes that he is a little flirtatious with her and doesn't seem to fall for her act. And that's it - romance done. Seriously??? Other than a little flirty flirt conversation or two this couple hardly interacted. And we went from no she wasn't in love, to kind of declaring she was, to one kiss and in the next breath they were engaged - all in the final paragraph I might add.
The romance was lazy. The grift part kind of interesting but the author made the crims just too noble. And as for the suffragette part - that was actually based on real events - so the only actual interesting/dramatic part of the tale really isn't down to the author - she is just re-telling facts.
Mash all those elements together and you have this ho-hum mess of a story that zigs and zags from one story thread to another - rather badly I might add.
Unfortunately none of the stories separately were very well done except the suffragette/prison story thread - but then that was dropped like a hot potato and hardly ever referenced again once the women were out of prison. Weird to make it so central and the best dramatic part of this book and then just let it slip away.
The con/scam thread was a little confusing, Lizzie's role is rather minor in part 1 of it - and her cries of "i knew it would go wrong but he wouldn't listen to me" were hopelessly ineffectual. Other than batting her eyes and running away she contributed nothing much of anything. In part 2 of the scam, yes it was her idea. But now I know her back story and have met her criminal family and no way do I believe in Lizzie now - how hopelessly naive she is, that she's virtuous (???) which just didn't fit - but no, she comes from a 'noble' kind of criminal element - Yeah, right.
And then there was the romance - it was insta-love on his part, and attraction on hers. He sees those piercing blue eyes and straight spine and that's it - he's in love. She likes that he is a little flirtatious with her and doesn't seem to fall for her act. And that's it - romance done. Seriously??? Other than a little flirty flirt conversation or two this couple hardly interacted. And we went from no she wasn't in love, to kind of declaring she was, to one kiss and in the next breath they were engaged - all in the final paragraph I might add.
The romance was lazy. The grift part kind of interesting but the author made the crims just too noble. And as for the suffragette part - that was actually based on real events - so the only actual interesting/dramatic part of the tale really isn't down to the author - she is just re-telling facts.
Mash all those elements together and you have this ho-hum mess of a story that zigs and zags from one story thread to another - rather badly I might add.
November 8, 2017
I want to start by pointing out that the Goodreads blurb for this book is not accurate. First of all this is not a murder mystery, Elizabeth does not scour Washington, DC for a killer. The story does not take place in 1920's but few years earlier, in 1917-1918. Lastly, one of the main character's name is Gideon, not Gabriel. (The blurb on Amazon website is more accurate)
Now that we cleared this I must say I really enjoyed City of Lies. I found the time period very interesting and I enjoyed reading about the suffragist movement. The writing is very engaging and the pacing is great. I was never bored, I wanted to keep turning pages and read about Elizabeth's adventures. This book does have a few flaws that in any other book would have caused me to lower my rating, but City of Lies was so entertaining I decided to forgive them. These are the things I didn't love:
1. Insta-love, especially on Gideon's side. I wanted Elizabeth and Gideon's relationship to have more depth and more complexity, I wanted it to grow and develop slowly.
2. We are constantly told that Elizabeth is this incredible, amazing woman like no other. Gideon, Anna, and Mrs. Bates all rave about how different from anyone else she is, but we are never shown this side of her character. Yes, she is clever, resourceful, and street smart, but to imply that she is so much better than everyone else is a stretch.
3. The ending is too neat and tidy for my taste. City of Lies is supposed to be the first book in the series and it's hard to imagine how Elizabeth's story will continue when the ending was wrapped up like a pretty package with a bow on top.
As I mentioned earlier I still very much enjoyed this book. The City of Lies is a fun romp full of adventures and likable characters, and it’s an interesting read despite some flaws. I will definitely pick up the second book.
*ARC provided by the publisher via Edelweiss
Now that we cleared this I must say I really enjoyed City of Lies. I found the time period very interesting and I enjoyed reading about the suffragist movement. The writing is very engaging and the pacing is great. I was never bored, I wanted to keep turning pages and read about Elizabeth's adventures. This book does have a few flaws that in any other book would have caused me to lower my rating, but City of Lies was so entertaining I decided to forgive them. These are the things I didn't love:
1. Insta-love, especially on Gideon's side. I wanted Elizabeth and Gideon's relationship to have more depth and more complexity, I wanted it to grow and develop slowly.
2. We are constantly told that Elizabeth is this incredible, amazing woman like no other. Gideon, Anna, and Mrs. Bates all rave about how different from anyone else she is, but we are never shown this side of her character. Yes, she is clever, resourceful, and street smart, but to imply that she is so much better than everyone else is a stretch.
3. The ending is too neat and tidy for my taste. City of Lies is supposed to be the first book in the series and it's hard to imagine how Elizabeth's story will continue when the ending was wrapped up like a pretty package with a bow on top.
As I mentioned earlier I still very much enjoyed this book. The City of Lies is a fun romp full of adventures and likable characters, and it’s an interesting read despite some flaws. I will definitely pick up the second book.
*ARC provided by the publisher via Edelweiss
October 25, 2018
Victoria Thompson, author of City of Lies, is an award winning author of the Gaslight Series, a series of 22 'cozy' mysteries that take place in turn of the century New York City.
City of Lies is the first in the Counterfeit Lady series featuring Elizabeth Miles, a grifter. I decided to read it as I have received an ARC of the second in the series, City of Secrets.
I have not read too many cozy mysteries. But I am glad that I ran into this one.
The plot revolves around cons perpetrated by Elizabeth and her cohorts. VERY interesting premise.
Very interesting lead character as well. Could you like a woman who lies for a living? Perhaps, because Thompson does a great job of weaving good things about Elizabeth into the story. In the process, the reader learns about the women's suffrage movement. Thompson herself did not know much about it and certainly did not know the suffering the suffragists went through to get the vote for women.
So this book involves true historical events, illegal activities, romance and justice. Looking forward to #2. BTW, the author's note is well worth the read. Thompson emphasizes what is true in her book and what she made up for drama effect. Thank you Victoria!!
4 stars
City of Lies is the first in the Counterfeit Lady series featuring Elizabeth Miles, a grifter. I decided to read it as I have received an ARC of the second in the series, City of Secrets.
I have not read too many cozy mysteries. But I am glad that I ran into this one.
The plot revolves around cons perpetrated by Elizabeth and her cohorts. VERY interesting premise.
Very interesting lead character as well. Could you like a woman who lies for a living? Perhaps, because Thompson does a great job of weaving good things about Elizabeth into the story. In the process, the reader learns about the women's suffrage movement. Thompson herself did not know much about it and certainly did not know the suffering the suffragists went through to get the vote for women.
So this book involves true historical events, illegal activities, romance and justice. Looking forward to #2. BTW, the author's note is well worth the read. Thompson emphasizes what is true in her book and what she made up for drama effect. Thank you Victoria!!
4 stars
May 21, 2018
It was an OK novel: a little historical, a little romantic, and a little ‘thriller-y’. The action takes place in 1917 in New York. I finished the book, although I didn’t like it very much. The first half was actually much better than the second.
Elizabeth, the protagonist, is a grifter. She and her friends con people, but this time, the con has gone terribly wrong. Their mark – the ruthless businessman Oscar Thornton – is onto them and wants his money back. She is running for her life, and the safest place she finds is a suffragists’ demonstration in front of the White House. The suffragists, Elizabeth included, are arrested and sent to prison.
Elizabeth doesn’t care a fig about the suffrage movement, but the prison is the safest place for her right now. It keeps her away from Thornton. On the other hand, she likes the women suffragists: educated, sophisticated, friendly, and principled. She has never encountered such women before. She pretends to be one of them, helps and supports them in the horrible prison, and at some point becomes one of them.
So far, the tension mounts nicely, and the pace of the story keeps the reader to the pages. Then the women are freed, and the second part of the book starts. And the story deteriorates. Thornton seems omnipotent, always one step ahead of Elizabeth. She, contrary to the logic of the plot, develops a silly love interest in an absurdly honest lawyer. Instead of leaving town, she shuttles from place to place, always getting in the way of Thornton or his mean bodyguards. She is supposed to be a smart, tough con-women, but the author makes her feel like a stupid, naive, and helpless damsel. And she lies to everyone.
With the heroine sliding from interesting and capable to vapid and incompetent, the book rapidly becomes boring despite the constant threat of Thornton and his henchmen. I had trouble finishing it.
Elizabeth, the protagonist, is a grifter. She and her friends con people, but this time, the con has gone terribly wrong. Their mark – the ruthless businessman Oscar Thornton – is onto them and wants his money back. She is running for her life, and the safest place she finds is a suffragists’ demonstration in front of the White House. The suffragists, Elizabeth included, are arrested and sent to prison.
Elizabeth doesn’t care a fig about the suffrage movement, but the prison is the safest place for her right now. It keeps her away from Thornton. On the other hand, she likes the women suffragists: educated, sophisticated, friendly, and principled. She has never encountered such women before. She pretends to be one of them, helps and supports them in the horrible prison, and at some point becomes one of them.
So far, the tension mounts nicely, and the pace of the story keeps the reader to the pages. Then the women are freed, and the second part of the book starts. And the story deteriorates. Thornton seems omnipotent, always one step ahead of Elizabeth. She, contrary to the logic of the plot, develops a silly love interest in an absurdly honest lawyer. Instead of leaving town, she shuttles from place to place, always getting in the way of Thornton or his mean bodyguards. She is supposed to be a smart, tough con-women, but the author makes her feel like a stupid, naive, and helpless damsel. And she lies to everyone.
With the heroine sliding from interesting and capable to vapid and incompetent, the book rapidly becomes boring despite the constant threat of Thornton and his henchmen. I had trouble finishing it.
November 29, 2017
City of Lies is more than just an intriguing mystery. It is an exciting, elegantly written historical fiction story about strong women, crime, betrayal, and wit. This one has all the makings of a fun crime novel, with the addition of women fighting for what they believe in, and rising above their times! For those who love historical fiction with flare and cleverness, this one is for you!
I was pleasantly intrigued by this book. Though, the synopsis doesn't quite match the true feel of the story, the book itself was an exciting read! I am a little ashamed to admit that I did not remember learning about the women's movement involved in this story, and in history, that ultimately led to our right to vote, but I am most definitely going to be doing more research to learn all that I can. I felt like that was an amazing addition to the story.
The plot of the story was spectacularly written. Elizabeth Miles was on the run from a man named Oscar Thornton because she and her brother, Jake, had cheated him out of a large sum of money. She found an opportunity to escape his sight by joining the Suffragists in a protest in front of the white house, and things quickly spiraled from there. She became involved in their cause, and emotionally connected with several members, and not only had an amazing character transformation, but also found ways to aid her escape from Thornton's hunt.
Elizabeth was so fascinating. She was clever, witty, sneaky, and brave. She was a great con artist, but also had a few hidden morals that showed throughout the story. I felt like she almost measured up to Audrey Rose from Stalking Jack the Ripper, and Lady Helen from The Dark Days Club, in my eyes. I loved seeing the emotional changes she faced, and I am excited to see what happens next!
The rest of the characters were a little less developed than I would have liked. But, they were still enjoyable nonetheless. Gideon was a fair match to Elizabeth's wit. Anna was an amazing friend, and strong woman, and Mrs. Bates and Mrs. Vanderslice were both strong characters.
I truly loved how the story mixed a large amount of historical aspects in with the fictional story of Elizabeth and her con-artistry. The history of the Suffragists was used to help shape Elizabeth's character, and to shape the time of the story, which led to a fair amount of enjoy-ability in the world building. I was able to get a true feel of the time from the description and imagery the author used. I cannot wait to read the next installment in the series! 4.5 stars for this one!
"I promise I will never be boring. I will be the most interesting woman you've ever met."
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with this free e-copy in exchange for my honest review!
I was pleasantly intrigued by this book. Though, the synopsis doesn't quite match the true feel of the story, the book itself was an exciting read! I am a little ashamed to admit that I did not remember learning about the women's movement involved in this story, and in history, that ultimately led to our right to vote, but I am most definitely going to be doing more research to learn all that I can. I felt like that was an amazing addition to the story.
The plot of the story was spectacularly written. Elizabeth Miles was on the run from a man named Oscar Thornton because she and her brother, Jake, had cheated him out of a large sum of money. She found an opportunity to escape his sight by joining the Suffragists in a protest in front of the white house, and things quickly spiraled from there. She became involved in their cause, and emotionally connected with several members, and not only had an amazing character transformation, but also found ways to aid her escape from Thornton's hunt.
Elizabeth was so fascinating. She was clever, witty, sneaky, and brave. She was a great con artist, but also had a few hidden morals that showed throughout the story. I felt like she almost measured up to Audrey Rose from Stalking Jack the Ripper, and Lady Helen from The Dark Days Club, in my eyes. I loved seeing the emotional changes she faced, and I am excited to see what happens next!
The rest of the characters were a little less developed than I would have liked. But, they were still enjoyable nonetheless. Gideon was a fair match to Elizabeth's wit. Anna was an amazing friend, and strong woman, and Mrs. Bates and Mrs. Vanderslice were both strong characters.
I truly loved how the story mixed a large amount of historical aspects in with the fictional story of Elizabeth and her con-artistry. The history of the Suffragists was used to help shape Elizabeth's character, and to shape the time of the story, which led to a fair amount of enjoy-ability in the world building. I was able to get a true feel of the time from the description and imagery the author used. I cannot wait to read the next installment in the series! 4.5 stars for this one!
"I promise I will never be boring. I will be the most interesting woman you've ever met."
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with this free e-copy in exchange for my honest review!
December 20, 2017
4.5/5
Mon avis en Français
My English review
I must say that I did not know about the novel at all but I really had a great time with the story. What to say? Everything seemed fantastic!
We discover Elizabeth Miles, a young girl who used to live on the margins of society. With her friends, she usually organizes scams to steal money from dishonest rich men. But while she usually does not have problems after these acts, the latest victim is far from appreciating it. Determined to find Elizabeth and to force her to return his money, or even to kill her, he will pursue her without respite. Yet the young woman, full of resources, does not hesitate to place herself in a feminist manifestation that demands the right to vote in order to escape her pursuers. Putting herself as a woman she is not, she gets arrested by the police and she is sent with all the others to jail. And you suspect that she is one of the only girls who absolutely wants to stay there to be safe. But then, under these conditions, she did not expect to connect so easily to Anna, a young febrile woman or to the matriarch of the group for which she will have great esteem. Elizabeth will help them understand how to act in jail and she will watch over them as best as she can. In parallel, we discover Gabriel, the son of the matriarch who arrives in town determined to save these young women. Thornton, allying himself with him, is also very interested to get them out!
I will not say more because it would be very easy to tell you everything but I can tell you that this novel is a pretty little pearl. I loved to follow Elizabeth, see her change at the touch of these young women and see her regret not to be a better person. It was also really interesting to have such a big part devoted to the cause that these women fight for! It was fascinating to have such a theme and it is true that we realize what these women have suffered a lot in order to advance their rights.
It was really a great story and I loved all the characters, be it Gabriel is his frankness, Elizabeth and her scams, Thornthon and his wickedness, Anna and her naïveté, and many other things that I’ll leave you discover!
Mon avis en Français
My English review
I must say that I did not know about the novel at all but I really had a great time with the story. What to say? Everything seemed fantastic!
We discover Elizabeth Miles, a young girl who used to live on the margins of society. With her friends, she usually organizes scams to steal money from dishonest rich men. But while she usually does not have problems after these acts, the latest victim is far from appreciating it. Determined to find Elizabeth and to force her to return his money, or even to kill her, he will pursue her without respite. Yet the young woman, full of resources, does not hesitate to place herself in a feminist manifestation that demands the right to vote in order to escape her pursuers. Putting herself as a woman she is not, she gets arrested by the police and she is sent with all the others to jail. And you suspect that she is one of the only girls who absolutely wants to stay there to be safe. But then, under these conditions, she did not expect to connect so easily to Anna, a young febrile woman or to the matriarch of the group for which she will have great esteem. Elizabeth will help them understand how to act in jail and she will watch over them as best as she can. In parallel, we discover Gabriel, the son of the matriarch who arrives in town determined to save these young women. Thornton, allying himself with him, is also very interested to get them out!
I will not say more because it would be very easy to tell you everything but I can tell you that this novel is a pretty little pearl. I loved to follow Elizabeth, see her change at the touch of these young women and see her regret not to be a better person. It was also really interesting to have such a big part devoted to the cause that these women fight for! It was fascinating to have such a theme and it is true that we realize what these women have suffered a lot in order to advance their rights.
It was really a great story and I loved all the characters, be it Gabriel is his frankness, Elizabeth and her scams, Thornthon and his wickedness, Anna and her naïveté, and many other things that I’ll leave you discover!
October 10, 2020
"A Counterfeit Lady" novel series, the newest of author Victoria Thompson's historical fiction series is riveting, charming, and most gratifying. This first book in the series introduces us to clever, bright and sly grifter, Elizabeth Miles, who comes from a family of con men. It's 1917, Washington City. The story opens with her and her brother working a con on a rather sinister con man himself. All was moving along well until the mark was out his money and he suddenly had his sites set on retribution against the two siblings. Getting his money back won't be enough and he sics his two goons on pursuing Elizabeth as she flees the scene of the con. As she's running toward the White House with the henchmen in hot pursuit, she insinuates herself into a large group of women protesting for the right to vote and is spared the wrath of the conned mark, at least for the moment. She really doesn't know much about these women of the suffragist movement but quickly falls in with them and develops an admiration for their commitment to the cause. Elizabeth is safe for the moment and hopes she can quietly return to New York City once things cool down. However, she suddenly has gone from the frying pan and into the fire. She quickly develops the respect of the suffragists as she imparts some of her street smarts to these genteel women.
There's lots of action in this story and never a dull moment. The author has done her research and added historical elements of the day, which are spot on. She even provides a few notes regarding the historical record at the end of the book and sets the record straight on how she condensed some of that record for dramatic purposes.
I actually read the second book in the series (City of Secrets) first and enjoyed it so much that I was impelled to go back and read the first book in the series. If historical fiction with a high-spirited, plucky and courageous female protagonist at is center appeals, then this is definitely a series you won't want to miss.
There's lots of action in this story and never a dull moment. The author has done her research and added historical elements of the day, which are spot on. She even provides a few notes regarding the historical record at the end of the book and sets the record straight on how she condensed some of that record for dramatic purposes.
I actually read the second book in the series (City of Secrets) first and enjoyed it so much that I was impelled to go back and read the first book in the series. If historical fiction with a high-spirited, plucky and courageous female protagonist at is center appeals, then this is definitely a series you won't want to miss.
July 11, 2018
A con artist escaping from an angry victim gets mixed up with the women's suffrage movement. The ensuing stint in prison, complete with force-feeding, leads to her introduction to New York's social elite.
It's an interesting premise to have the heroine of a series be a grifter. Alas, she is a bit of a Mary Sue of a grifter--she only targets people who are themselves crooked and is so stunningly beautiful and intelligent and interesting etc. that men AND women can't help loving her. I feel that Thompson's lost an opportunity to create an imperfect main character whom we love despite her failings; Elizabeth just doesn't have much depth for me.
Still, as I said, interesting premise and Thompson executes it with a seasoned author's skill. I wasn't crazy about narrator Kate Forbes's voice, which seemed a little old and noir-ish for what essentially was a lighthearted romp, and there were such long silences between chapters and sections that I kept thinking my Audible app had crashed (which it does from time to time). But as my introduction to Thompson's work, it was enjoyable enough that I might read the next book one of these days.
Side note: There seems to be a disconnect between the book's blurb, which sets the story in the 1920s, and the cover, which suggests pre-WWI. I'm sure I remember the war being mentioned as being in its early stages in the book, which would put the action in 1914 or 1915, but I didn't get a very strong sense of the era. I looked at the cover of the next book and was even more confused as the cars look 1920s but the model is distinctly Edwardian. Possibly there's an Author's Note in the text version of the book that explains the background to Elizabeth's prison experience, or possibly it's one of those books where the historical background is just there as color. I'd welcome some elucidation from other readers.
It's an interesting premise to have the heroine of a series be a grifter. Alas, she is a bit of a Mary Sue of a grifter--she only targets people who are themselves crooked and is so stunningly beautiful and intelligent and interesting etc. that men AND women can't help loving her. I feel that Thompson's lost an opportunity to create an imperfect main character whom we love despite her failings; Elizabeth just doesn't have much depth for me.
Still, as I said, interesting premise and Thompson executes it with a seasoned author's skill. I wasn't crazy about narrator Kate Forbes's voice, which seemed a little old and noir-ish for what essentially was a lighthearted romp, and there were such long silences between chapters and sections that I kept thinking my Audible app had crashed (which it does from time to time). But as my introduction to Thompson's work, it was enjoyable enough that I might read the next book one of these days.
Side note: There seems to be a disconnect between the book's blurb, which sets the story in the 1920s, and the cover, which suggests pre-WWI. I'm sure I remember the war being mentioned as being in its early stages in the book, which would put the action in 1914 or 1915, but I didn't get a very strong sense of the era. I looked at the cover of the next book and was even more confused as the cars look 1920s but the model is distinctly Edwardian. Possibly there's an Author's Note in the text version of the book that explains the background to Elizabeth's prison experience, or possibly it's one of those books where the historical background is just there as color. I'd welcome some elucidation from other readers.
March 19, 2019
I am grateful to the Meridian Library for a copy. This is the first book in The Counterfeit Lady historical series. It takes in the 1900s at the time of when the USA is preparing to enter World War I and women were demanding to vote. The protagonist is fully developed and across with her views. The story is told from her viewpoint. The other characters need more development. The descriptions set you in the area.
Elizabeth is a grifter aka con man. She is working with a couple of gritters and they have relieved a from a man of a large sum and its collapses and she is running for her life. She managed to hide with a group of suffragist and went with them when arrested to jail. This group of suffrage was sent to a workhouse. Before she realized it cared about what happened. Will Elizabeth escaped the thugs after her? I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS BOOK.
Elizabeth is a grifter aka con man. She is working with a couple of gritters and they have relieved a from a man of a large sum and its collapses and she is running for her life. She managed to hide with a group of suffragist and went with them when arrested to jail. This group of suffrage was sent to a workhouse. Before she realized it cared about what happened. Will Elizabeth escaped the thugs after her? I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS BOOK.
March 31, 2021
I liked the anti-hero MC. It was good to see the accurate portrayal of suffrage and how it entirely was comprised of rich, white women. Racism was alive and well in the book; between the actions, indifference, and language used. Accurate but sad!
That being said, it was interesting how the movement was basically abandoned and nearly forgotten when they were all out of jail by all but Mrs. Bates.
I liked that Anna was but didn't know it. Her self-discovery was nice to see. And the fact that Elizabeth had no qualms about it was even more refreshing.
The romance was rather abrupt and Gideon was much too good and dumb to be able to pull off chemistry.
All in all, it was fun but a bit on the lighter side of things.
That being said, it was interesting how the movement was basically abandoned and nearly forgotten when they were all out of jail by all but Mrs. Bates.
I liked that Anna was but didn't know it. Her self-discovery was nice to see. And the fact that Elizabeth had no qualms about it was even more refreshing.
The romance was rather abrupt and Gideon was much too good and dumb to be able to pull off chemistry.
All in all, it was fun but a bit on the lighter side of things.
January 11, 2019
This book is very wrongly labeled. It’s not a mystery, nor is it set in the 1920s (really it’s in WW1). Also the description mentions she gets involved with a group of women but no mention that they are women fighting for the right to vote. This played huge part in the book. It was an alright book but long winded at times and I felt sad there wasn’t more mystery in it. So solid 3 stars!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 590 reviews