Carmen's Reviews > Iranian Love Stories

Iranian Love Stories by Jane Deuxard
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
25353295
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: non-fiction, she-says, french-author, graphic-novel, he-says, published2021, traditionally-published
Read 2 times. Last read January 29, 2022.

This is a depressing book about living in Iran. Like living in any place where religion makes the rules, it is an oppressive and horrifying patriarchy. Both men and women suffer a lot. Sex is forbidden outside marriage. Women then resort to what born-again Christians do - everything but. They give blowjobs and have anal sex in order to remain 'virgins.' The government can do virginity tests at any time, resulting in a lot of women being raped. Rape is quite common because of the reality set up by religion in which any woman who is not 100% beyond reproach is then considered 'dirty.' 'Police' can stop you at any time and pretty much do whatever they want to you.

Men are beaten and forced to pay bribes if caught doing illegal things like drinking alcohol or listening to rock music. Men are forced into marriages they don't want, just like women. Women can be forced to take virginity tests before marriage. Men have mandated military service which has been extended to longer periods.

The only ones not suffering are the mullahs, who make the rules. They fuck prostitutes and claim it is okay because of 'temporary marriage' that they can enact and then annul. The rules they make apply to everyone except them.

The government surveils everyone constantly and is always alert to catch you doing something 'bad.' There is very little privacy and you are literally risking your life by having sexual relations outside of marriage. Everyone lives in constant fear.

It honestly sounds like a fucking nightmare, and it's important to remember this is where all religions pretty much end up when allowed unlimited power. This is why it's important to keep religion out of government.

There's already a lot of move towards the Christian right trying to take control in a lot of spaces right now in the U.S. of A. People have fear of them overturning Roe vs. Wade, then coming for banning all gay marriage and gay adoption etc. On the micro-level they are working hard to get books banned in both school and public libraries, which is scarily effective. They take over the local boards and then just enforce their religious beliefs on everyone else. A lot of anti-Semitism is on the rise, and a lot of book-banning is occurring of books written by Jewish, POC, and LGBTQIA+ authors. Eventually are we going to get to a point where the Holocaust will no longer be taught in schools? The remaining Holocaust survivors are dying out. They banned The Complete Maus in a TN school district, ostensibly because it had a swear in it and a naked mouse in it, but really it is because they are anti-Semites and want to erase history, and although TN is in the news right now, it's happening EVERYWHERE.

Of course, it's not really about religion, it's about control. Controlling other people is the biggest desire of these groups and the people behind them. Religion is simply an effective and emotional and powerful way to get support for totalitarianism.

TL;DR - Read it and weep. Pity Iranians? Never think 'it can't happen here.' Please look at history of other countries, current events in other countries, and then take a look at your own country. I'm not only talking to U.S. citizens here. Do not feel secure and like your country is immune. It's not.
60 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Iranian Love Stories.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
January 29, 2022 – Started Reading
January 29, 2022 – Shelved
January 29, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Vegan Fabulous review, Carmen. It does sound like a depressing book and I appreciate your additional thoughts. It can be a depressing world.


Carmen Lisa wrote: "Fabulous review, Carmen. It does sound like a depressing book and I appreciate your additional thoughts. It can be a depressing world."

Lisa, thank you. Unfortunately, recent events in the last six years have really crushed my worldview. I no longer have much faith in humanity and feel quite depressive about where the world is going. I suppose my happy, pleasant optimism couldn't last forever. But I mourn losing it.


message 3: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Vegan Carmen wrote: "Unfortunately, recent events in the last six years have really crushed my worldview. I no longer have much faith in humanity and feel quite depressive about where the world is going. I suppose my happy, pleasant optimism couldn't last forever. But I mourn losing it."

Carmen, I’m sorry. Maybe you can get it back for just certain things. I’ve despaired about humanity for decades now but 2016 kind of clinched the deal and then every year after that for a while just solidified it.


Carmen Carmen, I’m sorry. Maybe you can get it back for just certain things. I’ve despaired about humanity for decades now but 2016 kind of clinched the deal and then every year after that for a while just solidified it.

:( Hugs.


message 5: by Margie (new)

Margie Great review, Carmen!


Carmen Margie wrote: "Great review, Carmen!"

Thank you, Margie!


message 7: by Mimi (new)

Mimi Excellent review, Carmen. I never know what to say other than thank you for reading this book and bringing attention to it.


Carmen Mimi wrote: "Excellent review, Carmen. I never know what to say other than thank you for reading this book and bringing attention to it."

You're welcome, Mimi! And thanks!


message 9: by Mir (new)

Mir I feel you, Carmen. I wasn't exactly an optimist to begin with, and things are so much worse than I imagined...
Hugs.


message 10: by Joe (last edited Jan 31, 2022 05:24PM) (new)

Joe Carmen wrote: "Of course, it's not really about religion, it's about control. Controlling other people is the biggest desire of these groups and the people behind them. Religion is simply an effective and emotional and powerful way to get support for totalitarianism."

Yes. Authors like Margaret Atwood have warned us. It's up to us to keep religion out of legislation. This rabbit hole is a very scary one to go down, Moneypenny. I remember things that happened when I was a kid, like having to recite the Pledge of Allegiance in the morning and stand for a prayer service at sporting events because reasons.


message 11: by Barbara (new)

Barbara You make a lot of excellent points Carmen. Great review.


Carmen Mir wrote: "I feel you, Carmen. I wasn't exactly an optimist to begin with, and things are so much worse than I imagined...
Hugs."


Thanks, Miriam. We can be depressed together. LOL Hugs.


Carmen Yes. Authors like Margaret Atwood have warned us. It's up to us to keep religion out of legislation. This rabbit hole is a very scary one to go down, Moneypenny. I remember things that happened when I was a kid, like having to recite the Pledge of Allegiance in the morning and stand for a prayer service at sporting events because reasons.

I agree it's terrifying, Joseph. Banning books is so awful and the fact that book-banning is gaining a lot of traction now is so troubling. It's surprising and upsetting how easy it is for them to do.


Carmen Barbara wrote: "You make a lot of excellent points Carmen. Great review."

Thank you so much, Barbara.


message 15: by Jasmine (new)

Jasmine Excellent review, Carmen!


message 16: by Mir (new)

Mir A friend who is a middle school librarian said the banning is much more advanced than most people realize -- for every book that makes the news over disputes, there are 100 that have already quietly been removed without any attention.


message 17: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Vegan Mir wrote: "A friend who is a middle school librarian said the banning is much more advanced than most people realize -- for every book that makes the news over disputes, there are 100 that have already quietl..."

Mir, That's so depressing and infuriating but I guess not surprising.


Carmen Jasmine wrote: "Excellent review, Carmen!"

Thank you, Jasmine!


Carmen Mir wrote: "A friend who is a middle school librarian said the banning is much more advanced than most people realize -- for every book that makes the news over disputes, there are 100 that have already quietly been removed without any attention..."

Yes, of course. And the fear of backlash freezes people and makes them simply NOT buy titles at the onset. It's a horrible effect. Quite sad.


message 20: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Vegan Carmen wrote: Yes, of course. And the fear of backlash freezes people and makes them simply NOT buy titles at the onset. It's a horrible effect. Quite sad. ."

It is sad. If we ever congratulate ourselves for making progres we have a lot to remind us how we haven't.


Carmen It is sad. If we ever congratulate ourselves for making progres we have a lot to remind us how we haven't.

So true, and true in many realms.


message 22: by Lea (new)

Lea Carmen, this is absolutely horrifying, it reminds me of the dystopian world described in The Handmaid's Tale . It is important to defend our freedom at all costs. Terrific review, with important warnings.


Carmen Lea wrote: "Carmen, this is absolutely horrifying, it reminds me of the dystopian world described in The Handmaid's Tale . It is important to defend our freedom at all costs. Terrific review, with important warnings...."

Thank you, Lea! Yes, it is very scary.


message 24: by Fran (new)

Fran Excellent review, Carmen!🌹


Carmen Fran wrote: "Excellent review, Carmen!🌹"

Thank you, Fran.


message 26: by Cheri (new)

Cheri Excellent (if horrifying) review, Carmen! I see you read this at the beginning of the year, and already so many of these issues have further invaded our lives. Florida's "Don't Say Gay" law/ban is one of the latest ones to shock me, almost as much as the words that come out of Marjorie Taylor Greene's mouth.


Carmen Excellent (if horrifying) review, Carmen! I see you read this at the beginning of the year, and already so many of these issues have further invaded our lives. Florida's "Don't Say Gay" law/ban is one of the latest ones to shock me, almost as much as the words that come out of Marjorie Taylor Greene's mouth.

Thank you, Cheri. It was horrifying. A good warning about what happens when religion takes over government.


back to top