Jr Bacdayan's Reviews > The Good Earth

The Good Earth by Pearl S. Buck
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
16587936
's review

really liked it

There is a gush of red, marvelous, and mysterious blood running through my veins. I am part Chinese. A race that has given me these small eyes and this yellowish complexion. A race that I have associated with frugality, hard work, mass production, internet restrictions, and Jackie Chan. China, I've only been there once as a tourist when I was a bit younger. And as much as I'd like to think that I am familiar with the Chinese culture, I have to admit that my knowledge about that is limited and my views about them a bit stereotypical. My Grandma, the real Chinese in the family, still brings Moon Cakes during the Chinese New Year and we do maintain fireworks when celebrating. We also drink herbal tea at home and have this uncanny favoritism for Chinese restaurants during family get-togethers. Aside from that, you could say that I'm really much more familiar with Filipino and Western cultures. So when I picked up this book, I didn't know what to expect. My only assurances were that it won the Pulitzer Prize and the author is a Nobel Prize winner. The Good Earth by Pearl S. Buck is a beautiful and sweeping story of farmer Wang Lu and his wife O-lan. The Land, the man, and their bond. This beautiful tale left me thirsty and craving for knowledge about this race that resides within me yet has not fully manifested itself. This may sound fancy but I have to say what I feel. This book made me fall in love with China, the Chinese culture, my Chinese roots.

“And roots, if they are to bear fruits, must be kept well in the soil of the land.”

The beauty of this sweeping tale can be understood by hearing its voice, its message. It whispers an earnest plea of the oldest kind, it whispers "Remember the land." The land which has provided for your father, your father's father, and countless generations before him. In this age of technology, internet, GMOs and fast foods, we forget the land. We ignore the Good Earth that has sustained the lives of everyone before us, and lives of this generation.

"If you sell the land it is the end.

And his two sons held him, one on either side, each holding his arm, and he held in his hand the warm loose earth. And they soothed him and they said over and over, the elder son and the second son,

Rest assured, our father, rest assured. The land is not to be sold.

But over the old man's head they looked at each other and smiled."

This book, written in the year 1931, exposes a problem that has continually been growing worse as each generation progresses. Each son telling his father "the land will not be sold" but inwardly smiling at this statement he knows to be untrue. Each son, each daughter, each generation, saying we will save this good earth. But for every tree he plants, he cuts down two more. For every bottle she recycles, she throws out two more. For every plot turned into a garden, there are two plots turned into garbage dumps. Each man, woman, son, daughter thinking about their self, their success apart from the land. They forget that their success lies with the land. They forget the Earth that has been good to them.

“Wang Lung sat smoking, thinking of the silver as it had lain upon the table. It had come out of the earth, this silver, out of the earth that he ploughed and turned and spent himself upon. He took his life from the earth; drop by drop by his sweat he wrung food from it and from the food, silver."

This book touches a lot of other social issues like Feminism, Slavery, Concubinage, Civil Wars, etc. I will not discuss much of these issues and will only say in passing that a different culture enabled them to see nothing wrong with things we in modern times would consider abhorrent and terrifying. Things like selling daughters, feet-binding, polygamy aren't limited to China as these practices can also be found in other Asian countries. But I marvel at how Mrs. Buck was able to make it feel natural despite all these cultural differences. She effected a normalcy on these weird practices that I didn't once think that I was unfamiliar with them. This speaks of her grace and her skill as a writer. She writes with a natural grace and an earnest plea. I am engrossed by her writing, her message, her book.

The Good Earth is a timeless, moving story that depicts the sweeping changes that have occurred not only in the lives of the Chinese people during the last century, but also of everyone who has walked a part of this good earth. She traces the whole cycle of life: its terrors, its passions, its ambitions, its rewards. Her beloved and brilliant novel is a universal tale of the destiny of mankind.

"Out of the Land we came and into it we must go."
252 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Good Earth.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 15, 2013 – Started Reading
September 15, 2013 – Shelved
September 16, 2013 –
page 200
56.02%
September 17, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-42 of 42 (42 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Jr! Too many days without any of your touching reviews!
And to reappear with such a marvellous one...
Identity is a shaky thing, but you managed to root your own heritage while paying homage to past generations. "Remember the land", as you say, or remember where you come from and be respectful to the ones who had to make sacrifices for us to be here and now.
I myself am grateful to be where I am at this precise moment, re-reading your review and wondering at such wise thoughts coming from someone so young. Thanks for sharing.


message 2: by Scarlet (new) - added it

Scarlet Brilliant review.


message 3: by Richard (new)

Richard Derus "The Good Earth is a timeless, moving story that depicts the sweeping changes that have occurred not only in the lives of the Chinese people during the last century, but also of everyone who has walked a part of this good earth. She traces the whole cycle of life: its terrors, its passions, its ambitions, its rewards. Her beloved and brilliant novel is a universal tale of the destiny of mankind."

Yes. This.


Samadrita What a fascinating review, Jr. I liked the way you interweaved your own family history, Chinese heritage with your experiences with the book. And I agree with Richard. Your last paragraph is simply dazzling.

Now to read this soon.


Teresa Great review, Jr. I was surprised by how much I liked this novel once I finally got around to reading it.


message 6: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue Excellent review. I have to get to this classic.


message 7: by Kalliope (new)

Kalliope Very sensitive and sensible review, Jr.


message 8: by Cathy (new)

Cathy DuPont Lovely written review, Jr. Always look forward to reading your thoughtful words.


message 9: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Dolors wrote: "Jr! Too many days without any of your touching reviews!
And to reappear with such a marvellous one...
Identity is a shaky thing, but you managed to root your own heritage while paying homage to pas..."


Been pretty busy with my studies... Ahh, I miss this place. Thank you. I really appreciate your kind words. I definitely should pay attention to my heritage more, I felt pretty guilty that I knew very little of Chinese practices. I guess this was what prompted my review to be a little personal. Anyway, this proved to be a good thing as I was able to connect with the story more. I am grateful that you are my friend, Dolors. I merely emulate the examples of those who have walked this good earth a little longer than I have. Cheers! I hope to be a little more active from now on. I don't want to keep missing your amazing reviews.


message 10: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Scarlet wrote: "Brilliant review."

Thanks, Scarlet!


message 11: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Richard wrote: ""The Good Earth is a timeless, moving story that depicts the sweeping changes that have occurred not only in the lives of the Chinese people during the last century, but also of everyone who has wa..."

Good books call for the good paragraphs. Was inspired by a backstory. Haha. Thanks, Richard!


message 12: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Samadrita wrote: "What a fascinating review, Jr. I liked the way you interweaved your own family history, Chinese heritage with your experiences with the book. And I agree with Richard. Your last paragraph is simply..."

Thank you, Samadrita. Blood is thicker than ink?! Hahaha. Kidding. Can't always write about your heritage, but I thought that I should grab the opportunity. Can't wait to read your review of this book. Bet it'll be dazzling as well.


message 13: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Teresa wrote: "Great review, Jr. I was surprised by how much I liked this novel once I finally got around to reading it."

The same thing happened to me. I didn't expect to like this book as much as I actually did. I thought that the premise of a farmer equated to a slow read, proved me wrong. Guess you can't judge a book by its summary. Thanks, Teresa!


message 14: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Sue wrote: "Excellent review. I have to get to this classic."

I appreciate it, Sue. You definitely should. No regrets here.


message 15: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Kalliope wrote: "Very sensitive and sensible review, Jr."

Thank you, Kalliope!


message 16: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Cathy wrote: "Lovely written review, Jr. Always look forward to reading your thoughtful words."

Hello, Cathy! Thanks! Always nice to bump into your comments and reviews. Looking forward to your next review too.


message 17: by Garima (new)

Garima Another brilliant review, Jr. You're an accomplished reader and it shows in your words.


Natasha Jacinto Ahhhhh JR your review makes me want to read it again! Beautiful take on an equally fantastic book. I remember now why the ending left me with a gaping hole in my insides.


message 19: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Garima wrote: "Another brilliant review, Jr. You're an accomplished reader and it shows in your words."

Ah, Garima, surely you jest. I have loads more to read and accomplish before I can call myself that. Nevertheless, thank you for your inspiring words.


message 20: by Jr (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jr Bacdayan Natasha wrote: "Ahhhhh JR your review makes me want to read it again! Beautiful take on an equally fantastic book. I remember now why the ending left me with a gaping hole in my insides."

Hey, Tasha! Good to see you here. :)) Well, it's definitely worth a re-read. I know I'll pick it up again sometime. Guess, that's the mark of a great book, you'll end up wanting seconds. Anyway, thank you. Now you know my secret. Haha ;) Yep, got a hole in my insides too.


message 21: by Mia (new) - added it

Mia Such a wonderful review. This book has been on my TBR list for the longest time. Your insightful review just convinced me to make it a priority.


Linda I loved your perspective on this, and your selection of quotes were awesome. Great review.


Sze-Leng Tan I am Chinese Malaysian and half way through the book. As you, I thought I knew Chinese culture and its people until I read this book and am deeply moved by it.


message 24: by Jasmine (new)

Jasmine I've just added myself to the long list of your admirers, Jr. Your sensitive review is beautiful and the quotes fit perfectly. I wish I could express myself like this in English. I've never read anything by Buck but I remember my parents loved her writing dearly and promoted her translated books in their bookshop.


Cecily Excellent review, with a personal touch.

It is a surprisingly gripping book, even today.


message 26: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Oh this is beautiful, Jr! Replete with tender and strong depictions of relevant themes, you do great justice in bringing its essence to the fore. Thank you.


Lynne King Jr, I have just come across your super review and have ordered the book!

Thank you!


Nicole I just finished this book last night, ready to write my review and came across yours. You are 100% spot on. It was very much a story worth reading <3 Adding it to my list of favorites!


message 29: by Melanie (new)

Melanie Love Beautiful review!


Sayalee Vadnerkar Perfect... more than perfect review... I am from India and as you mentioned the author makes all the weird practices sound like part of life. Yes, such practices and social issues, more or less, have been part of Asian countries. I can so much relate to your review. As I feel the same.


TXGAL1 Jr, thank you for writing such a beautiful and thoughtful review!


Olivia San miguel In ¨The Good Earth¨ Mrs. Buck describes the way of making tea as ¨to sprinkle the curled dry leaves upon the surface of the hot water¨ which is very queer and strange even to a Chinese villager, as a Chinese always pours hot water over the tea leaves....She names the Moon Cake as an item in the New Year festival, which is also a mistake. The Moon Cake is made for the Moon Festival.


Sherri There is no point in me writing a review or summary of this beautiful novel when Jr's review says it all. I would add as another theme, the personal trappings and character changes that happen when one comes from poverty into great wealth.


Andrew Willems This review has gotten me really excited to read the book!


Lynda Choquette Thank you for this wonderful review. I love this book.


message 36: by Ashleigh (new) - added it

Ashleigh Your review has made me rush this book to the top of my TBR


message 37: by Andy (new)

Andy Mooncakes are for the Mid-Autumn Festival ,not the Chinese New Year.


message 38: by Donna (new)

Donna You, yourself, are a very good writer, my dear. Fantastic review!!!


Jessaka Great personal review


Kathirael Great review!


&#x1f392; LMAOOO Jr! With that start I believe you and I are destined to be friends 💛💛 I also associate my Chinese blood with Jackie Chan


Sharon Albanese A wonderful review.


back to top