Jaidee's Reviews > The Elegance of the Hedgehog

The Elegance of the Hedgehog by Muriel Barbery
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
17295672
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: two-stars-books

2 " gee whiz...wtf do I say" stars !!!

Ok I am going to be cryptic or perhaps not ! The concierge, the little girl and the new neighbor upstairs will of course figure it out as will the multiple cats and don't forget those bloody camelias !

- Mama don't preach
-Get off the bloody soapbox
-Go on a date with Paulo Coelho (yes I did like Veronika Decides to Die more than this one)
- don't fetishize the Japanese
-pretentious prattle galore
-the protagonist is just as bloody snobby as the people she despises

Despite the above commentary there were a few passages of supreme beauty that prevented this little novel from moving into one star territory !!

144 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Elegance of the Hedgehog.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 9, 2013 – Shelved as: to-read
December 9, 2013 – Shelved
September 17, 2016 – Shelved as: jaidee-s-next-four-reads
September 17, 2017 – Shelved as: jaidee-s-not-to-exceed-33
March 7, 2018 –
8.0%
March 8, 2018 –
17.0%
March 11, 2018 –
23.0%
March 12, 2018 –
29.0%
March 17, 2018 –
33.0%
March 18, 2018 –
37.0%
March 26, 2018 –
99.0% "Review to follow in 1 or 2 days."
March 29, 2018 – Shelved as: two-stars-books
Started Reading
July 20, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 53 (53 new)


Bianca Ha. I know what you're saying although I seem to have been more generous in my rating (must be bad I got it on NG).


Jaidee Bianca wrote: "Ha. I know what you're saying although I seem to have been more generous in my rating (must be bad I got it on NG)."

haha....here kitty kitty :)


message 3: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Cat detectives? Haha


Jaidee Kelli wrote: "Cat detectives? Haha"

meow meow :)


message 5: by Suz (new)

Suz Bloody hell! Pretentious prattle made me laugh ;)


message 6: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen Well you said it all with those 2 stars. How was your trip?????


Jaidee Suzanne wrote: "Bloody hell! Pretentious prattle made me laugh ;)"

haha !


Jaidee Jen wrote: "Well you said it all with those 2 stars. How was your trip?????"

Very good trip thank you Jen. I hope you love Belize when you go !


Angela M We definitely saw this one differently, Jaidee but your review


Angela M Continued - is fantastic


Jaidee Angela M wrote: "Continued - is fantastic"

Haha you are too sweet ...lol....its ok to see things differently...thanx Angela :)


Angela M Jaidee , it’s one of the things I like about GR is getting different perspectives. And I always appreciate yours !


message 13: by Victoria (new)

Victoria Pretentious prattle, indeed! And I do love a good hedgehog meme.


Jaidee Victoria wrote: "Pretentious prattle, indeed! And I do love a good hedgehog meme."

He's so cute in the little glass 😊


message 15: by Teresa (new) - added it

Teresa Jaidee, I got through page 190 of this and then put it aside. For one thing, it felt as if it was going nowhere. I haven't officially abandoned it, but I just might.


Jaidee Teresa wrote: "Jaidee, I got through page 190 of this and then put it aside. For one thing, it felt as if it was going nowhere. I haven't officially abandoned it, but I just might."

I hear you sista....what kept me going were a few passages of very beautiful writing :)


message 17: by Teresa (new) - added it

Teresa Jaidee wrote: "...what kept me going were a few passages of very beautiful writing :)"

That's the only thing that got me to page 190! ;)


Rowena Haha, your review made me laugh! I did like it a lot but I read it maybe a decade ago and I do wonder how I'd react to the fetishization of Japanese culture if I read it now.


Jaidee Rowena wrote: "Haha, your review made me laugh! I did like it a lot but I read it maybe a decade ago and I do wonder how I'd react to the fetishization of Japanese culture if I read it now."

Hmmm yes that would be interesting !! Glad you got a giggle :)


message 20: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil HaHa! Jaidee. I have received two copies as gifts. I’ll get to this one some day. Despite your two stars, now I’m more curious about reading this one given your cryptic review :)


Jaidee Esil wrote: "HaHa! Jaidee. I have received two copies as gifts. I’ll get to this one some day. Despite your two stars, now I’m more curious about reading this one given your cryptic review :)"

Well I would say enjoy if I could....lol !


message 22: by Debbie "DJ" (new) - added it

Debbie "DJ" I have this one, but haven’t gotten around to reading. Thanks for the warning, time to donate....wtf, ha!


Jaidee Debbie "DJ" wrote: "I have this one, but haven’t gotten around to reading. Thanks for the warning, time to donate....wtf, ha!"

Give it a go and tell me what you think Debbie ?...you might take to it !


message 24: by Toni (new) - rated it 5 stars

Toni Loved your review, Jaidee. I read this quite awhile ago, more than five years I think, but for some reason I remember enjoying it's weirdness. Can't explain it though. Just a strange phase I guess. ; )


Jaidee Toni wrote: "Loved your review, Jaidee. I read this quite awhile ago, more than five years I think, but for some reason I remember enjoying it's weirdness. Can't explain it though. Just a strange phase I guess...."

Yes I know many of my GR and RL friends loved this one ! For me not so much !

Thanx Toni :)


Cecily I really enjoyed the book - but I love the closing illustration of your review!


Jaidee Cecily wrote: "I really enjoyed the book - but I love the closing illustration of your review!"

Hedgehogs rock !


Cheri I enjoyed your review, Jaidee, I really enjoyed the book, but I don't disagree with your reasons for not liking this one more.


Jaidee Cheri wrote: "I enjoyed your review, Jaidee, I really enjoyed the book, but I don't disagree with your reasons for not liking this one more."

You are awesome Cheri ☺


message 30: by Sue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sue This does seem one of those love/hate books. I came down on the love side but also love your review :-) Of course the hedgehog is a winner!


Jaidee Sue wrote: "This does seem one of those love/hate books. I came down on the love side but also love your review :-) Of course the hedgehog is a winner!"

Thanx Sue....didn't hate this one but found it kind of irritating :)


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) I hated this and gave up after 100 pages. Had the same problems as you did. I also enjoyed Veronika decides to die more than this one :))


Jaidee Adina wrote: "I hated this and gave up after 100 pages. Had the same problems as you did. I also enjoyed Veronika decides to die more than this one :))"

haha thanks Adina....I didn't hate as there were some sections that were just gorgeous but overall this was a dud :)

Let's go hang out with Veronika !!


Marialyce Have to say I fall into the hate category on this one. It was so pretentious that I wanted to quit but it was a group read from my library so I sadly had to finish. Ugh!


Jaidee Marialyce wrote: "Have to say I fall into the hate category on this one. It was so pretentious that I wanted to quit but it was a group read from my library so I sadly had to finish. Ugh!"

Well it's done but forever etched in your mind lol !


message 36: by MarilynW (new)

MarilynW That poor hedgehog's front legs don't look right 🤨 Great review, Jaidee! 😁


Margitte Lolol. LOVE your reaction!!!😁


message 38: by MarilynW (new)

MarilynW MarilynW wrote: "That poor hedgehog's front legs don't look right 🤨 Great review, Jaidee! 😁"

I just realized those must be the hedgehogs back legs. I'm just not used to seeing drunk hedgehogs 🤣


Jaidee Margitte wrote: "Lolol. LOVE your reaction!!!😁"

🤩🤩🐝


Jaidee MarilynW wrote: "MarilynW wrote: "That poor hedgehog's front legs don't look right 🤨 Great review, Jaidee! 😁"

I just realized those must be the hedgehogs back legs. I'm just not used to seeing drunk hedgehogs 🤣"


Omigosh so sorry I missed your first very funny comment Marilyn.

Maybe I was out having a few cocktails with the hedgehog 😸😸


message 41: by MarilynW (new)

MarilynW Jaidee wrote: "MarilynW wrote: "MarilynW wrote: "That poor hedgehog's front legs don't look right 🤨 Great review, Jaidee! 😁"

I just realized those must be the hedgehogs back legs. I'm just not used to seeing dru..."


🍺🍺 🥂🍺🍺😂


Melki For me the best thing about this book was that it faded very quickly from my memory.


Jaidee Melki wrote: "For me the best thing about this book was that it faded very quickly from my memory."

Uh oh....you had drinks with the hedgehog too!


message 44: by Margitte (last edited Aug 01, 2022 08:53PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Margitte Jaidee wrote: "Margitte wrote: "Lolol. LOVE your reaction!!!😁"

🤩🤩🐝"


-pretentious prattle galore - I'm going to create a book shelf with this as title. PERFECT!!!! 🤩🤩 This is one of the funniest reviews, ever. 😁😁😁 — of course with your permission, please!


Jaidee Tickled pink 💗 Margitte!


message 46: by Margitte (last edited Aug 07, 2022 07:40PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Margitte Jaidee, I landed on a website in which the 'Dreyfuss Code of Ratings' was discussed. I was thinking about you, and laughed again for your comments about this book. Lauren Tarshis, Dreyfuss. Since links are not allowed in comments, I will paste the short version of it for you. I was thinking of changing some of my book shelf titles. I was considering asking your permission to use '' -pretentious prattle galore'.

Here are some of the Dreyfuss code of ratings:
RB: Readable Banality
RP: Readable Piffle
NFM: Not For Me
DNF: Did Not Finish
DNR: Did Not Read
RP+1: One Step Up From "RP"
RPM: Readable Piffle Mystery - (my favorite—love the word 'piffle')
G: Good, Different, Holds My Attention
VB: Very Bad
NMS: Not My Style
PB: Pretty Boring
NBAA: Not Bad At All
RR: Readable
WOT: Waste Of Time

Just for interest' sake. :-))


Jaidee Margitte wrote: "Jaidee, I landed on a website in which the 'Dreyfuss Code of Ratings' was discussed. I was thinking about you, and laughed again for your comments about this book. Lauren Tarshis, Dreyfuss. Since l..."

Lol what a fun list !
By all means!


message 48: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen Lol....I'd say same thing you said to me: Time to move on, Brother!


Jaidee Jen wrote: "Lol....I'd say same thing you said to me: Time to move on, Brother!"

I did sweetheart....this is an oldie lol ! An oldie like us !


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Oh wow. This sounds like a mess. I am glad there were some decent passages that made this readable. I hope your next read is one you love!


« previous 1
back to top